한국   대만   중국   일본 
CBC News In Depth: Sikh politics in Canada
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20090601022355/http://www.cbc.ca:80/news/background/sikh-politics-canada/index.html
Young men wear International Sikh Youth Federation T-shirts at a Vaisakhi Parade, April 7, 2007, in Surrey, B.C. The ISYF is banned as a terrorist organization by the governments of Canada, the U.S., the U.K. and India. (CBC) Young men wear International Sikh Youth Federation T-shirts at a Vaisakhi Parade, April 7, 2007, in Surrey, B.C. The ISYF is banned as a terrorist organization by the governments of Canada, the U.S., the U.K. and India. (CBC)

In Depth

Sikh politics in Canada

Symbols and suits

Sikh extremism enters mainstream Canadian politics

Last Updated June 28, 2007

Every year, Canada's Sikh community enjoys colourful spring parades to mark Vaisakhi Day — the anniversary of the Sikh religion. But a disturbing brand of extremist politics has surfaced at some of these parades. The insignia of illegal organizations were on display this year at the parade in Surrey, B.C., and floats featured "martyr" pictures of Sikhs who the Canadian government considers guilty of terrorist crimes.

Martyrs portrayed on a parade float include Talwinder Parmar, left, the alleged leader of the Air India bomb plot, which took 331 lives on June 23, 1985. (CBC) Martyrs portrayed on a parade float include Talwinder Parmar, left, the leader of the Air India bomb plot, which took 331 lives on June 23, 1985. (CBC) The Khalistan flag is escorted on the Vaisakhi parade route in Surrey, B.C., on April 7, 2007. (CBC) The Khalistan flag is escorted on the Vaisakhi parade route in Surrey, B.C., on April 7, 2007. (CBC)

These shaheeds , or martyrs, are said by their supporters to be heroes of the armed struggle by Sikh extremists to carve out an independent nation called Khalistan in the Indian state of Punjab.

It was Khalistan separatists who blew up Air India Flight 182 on June 23, 1985. The bombing killed 329 passengers and crew, most of them Canadians. A second bomb killed two baggage handlers who were moving luggage to another Air India flight at Narita Airport in Tokyo.

Bomb-maker Inderjit Singh Reyat of Duncan, B.C., was convicted in both bombings. But the bomb plot leader, Talwinder Singh Parmar, fled the country in 1988 and was killed by the Indian police in 1992.

Martyr picture of Talwinder Singh Parmar, framed with gold tinsel, is displayed on a float at the Surrey Vaisakhi Parade, on April 7, 2007. (CBC) Martyr picture of Talwinder Singh Parmar, framed with gold tinsel, is displayed on a float at the Surrey Vaisakhi Parade, on April 7, 2007. (CBC)

Talwinder Parmar was the founder of the Babbar Khalsa, which is officially listed as a terrorist organization in the European Union, Canada, India, and the United States. Canadian courts have established that that Parmar was the mastermind of the Air India bombing. That makes him the worst mass murderer in Canadian history. Even so, Parmar was portrayed as a shaheed on two of the parade floats in Surrey this year.

Two leading Sikh politicians refused to attend the Surrey parade, saying it amounted to a glorification of terrorism. But many other politicians did attend — Conservative, Liberal and NDP. None of them condemned the Parmar pictures.

This silence shocked the Indian government and moderate Sikhs across Canada. They raised questions such as:

  • How does a separatist movement from halfway around the world still flourish in Canada, after taking hundreds of Canadian lives?
  • How can a mass murderer be honoured as a hero, without political leaders making any complaint?
Ajaib Singh Bagri, centre.(CBC) Ajaib Singh Bagri was co-founder of the Babbar Khalsa. "Until we kill 50,000 Hindus, we will not rest," he told the founding convention of the World Sikh Organization in 1984. (CBC)

Vaisakhi Day in Surrey, B.C.

On April 7, 2007, B.C. Premier Gordon Campbell, Surrey Mayor Dianne Watts and various federal and provincial politicians attended the Vaisakhi Day parade in Surrey, run by the Dashmesh Darbar temple.

The temple committee, with Khalistan logos on their jackets, took the stage alongside the politicians. Among them was Satinderpal Singh Gill, a former senior leader of the International Sikh Youth Federation. Since 2003, the ISYF, like the Babbar Khalsa, has been officially listed in Canada as an illegal terrorist organization.

Also attending the parade were two early supporters of the Babbar Khalsa: its co-founder, Ajaib Singh Bagri, and Ripudaman Singh Malik . Both were close associates of Talwinder Parmar and both were acquitted at the Air India bombing trial.

Parmar and the Air India bombing

The Dashmesh Darbar temple committee approved both of the floats bearing pictures of Talwinder Parmar. Parmar played a central role in the 1985 Air India bombing, although Sikh militants often claim otherwise.

  • At the trial of Malik and Bagri, Mr. Justice Ian Bruce Josephson of the B.C. Supreme Court concluded:

    "These hundreds of men, women and children were entirely innocent victims of a diabolical act of terrorism unparalleled until recently in aviation history and finding its roots in fanaticism at its basest and most inhumane level.… Now deceased, Talwinder Singh Parmar is generally acknowledged by both Crown and defence to have been the leader in the conspiracy to commit these crimes."

  • Three weeks before the bombing of Flight 182, Parmar was tailed by two CSIS officers to Vancouver Island, where he met Reyat for a test bombing.
  • Reyat was convicted twice — first for the Narita bomb and then for the Air India bomb. The two trials established that he assembled the bomb components and that he did so at the request of Talwinder Parmar.
  • Prior to the bombing, Parmar publicly urged attacks on Indian targets and said he would take the responsibility for such attacks on his shoulders. He was seen preaching that "Indian planes will fall from the sky" and urging his followers to "kill 50,000 Hindus."
  • CSIS wiretaps showed Parmar plotting to assassinate Rajiv Gandhi, who had succeeded his mother, Indira Gandhi, as India's prime minister. The wiretaps also suggest that Parmar kept in close touch with other suspects in the Air India conspiracy, including Reyat, and that he ordered the booking of the plane tickets.
Talwinder Singh Parmar, founder of the Babbar Khalsa, as portrayed on a Vaisakhi parade float in Surrey, B.C., on April 7, 2007. (CBC) Talwinder Singh Parmar, founder of the Babbar Khalsa, as portrayed on a Vaisakhi parade float in Surrey, B.C., on April 7, 2007. (CBC)

Even so, Parmar is revered as a martyr by Sikh extremists in Canada. Dashmesh Darbar temple president Sudager Singh Sandhu told CBC News "it's not proved he's terrorist. I can say you're a terrorist. You can say me a terrorist. It's easy to terrorist everybody.

"I love him. He's a great man. Because he never guilty," Sandhu added.

A spokesman for the temple, Manmohan Singh, insisted that Parmar is a martyr. "Talwinder Parmar is a martyr of the Sikh nation," he said.

When it was suggested that Parmar led the organization that carried out the bombing, Singh replied: "He claimed to be the leader, he said it, but that doesn't mean he's proven it. I can say anything, I can do that, that doesn't mean I am doing that."

What did the politicians say?

After the April 7, 2007, Vaisakhi parade in Surrey, B.C., Conservative MP Jim Abbott, who represented Prime Minister Stephen Harper at the parade, told CBC News he was "flabbergasted" to hear of these displays at the parade. Asked if he would have gone if he had known of them beforehand, Abbott replied, "no." The CBC reported that — but, four days later, Abbott reversed his position in an e-mail , saying "I will vigorously defend this event along with thousands of Canadians of Sikh faith who won't tolerate such a linkage."

However, Abbott's revised position was not adopted by the government. Asked if the Prime Minister endorsed Abbott's statement, Secretary of State for Multiculturalism Jason Kenney later said that the Conservatives probably would not have attended if they had known in advance of the extremism on display, and would be more careful in future.

Sukh Dhaliwal speaks at the Surrey Vaisakhi parade on April 7, 2007. At centre on Dhaliwal's left is Satinderpal Gill, a former senior leader of the banned International Sikh Youth Federation. (CBC) Sukh Dhaliwal speaks at the Surrey Vaisakhi parade on April 7, 2007. At centre on Dhaliwal's left is Satinderpal Gill, a former senior leader of the banned International Sikh Youth Federation. (CBC)

Conservative MP Nina Grewal, who also attended the parade, declined to be interviewed.

Liberal MP Sukh Dhaliwal was asked if he found the displays at the parade problematic. He did not. "I don't know why we're making a fuss about Surrey," he told the CBC.

NDP MP Penny Priddy said she was "disappointed" to hear what had happened but that "I don't regret going" to an event celebrating Sikh culture.

On similar grounds, Premier Campbell declined to criticize the parade and said he would continue to attend such events. However, a spokesman said a few days later that Cambpell was "upset" by the parade.

Liberal MP Ujjal Dosanjh, however, stayed away from the parade and decried the silence of his fellow politicians.

"Politicians sometimes believe that if they speak out against violence and hatred, somehow they are going to anger the entire community," he said.

"They are being afraid to speak out, and they choose consciously to not speak out," he added. "I have not heard any denunciation from any of the politicians from any of the political parties that went to that parade that found out that you had the glorification of Parmar and others who were killers. And nothing was said. And they were given the opportunity to say something."

Dave Hayer, a Liberal member of the B.C. legislative assembly, also skipped the parade. Although he's a Sikh politician from Surrey, he saw what was coming and stayed away.

Tara Singh Hayer in 1995. His 1998 murder is unsolved. (CBC) Tara Singh Hayer in 1995. His 1998 murder is unsolved. (CBC)

Family history may have something to do with that. In 1988, Hayer's father Tara Singh Hayer, who had written editorials criticizing Parmar and Bagri, denounced the Air India bombing in his newspaper — and was shot. He spent the rest of his life in a wheelchair and became a police witness in the Air India case against Ajaib Singh Bagri. But he never testified. In 1998, he was shot again — this time, fatally.

"It is different to celebrate your culture versus celebrating the terrorist," said Dave Hayer.

"If you celebrate them, it is wrong. And they told me, my constituents, they said, look, is it tomorrow they're gonna be celebrating the people who are killing our soldiers in Afghanistan? Because of freedom and the Charter of Rights? Are they gonna be carrying pictures of the people who are killing our soldiers in Afghanistan?"

Families of the Air India victims began complaining about politicians' association with Sikh extremists long before the 2007 Surrey Vaisakhi parade. In October 2006, Perviz Madon, whose husband, Sam, died in the Air India bombing, testified at John Major's judicial inquiry into the tragedy.

"We need to stop our politicians from attending those kind of events," she said. "I'm sorry, I know it's about your votes, but that's dirty business. You don't want to be associated with a group that is linked to terrorism. You don't want those kind of votes.… Canada is becoming a haven for criminals. It's a beautiful country. It's a great country, you know. We're just losing it, we're losing the grip on it. Something has to change."

So Hayer stayed away from the parade.

"A terrorist is a terrorist, and we should have no place for terrorism or people who support terrorism in Canada, period," he said. "If there are people who are terrorists and they are promoted as heroes, maybe it's the politicians' responsibility to say, listen, maybe we should think twice, should we participate, ethically and morally, in the parade."

Tarek Fatah, an immigrant from Punjab who is an outspoken critic of extremism in Canadian politics, said politicians are not fussy about where they get their votes.

"These guys have figured out Canadian politics," he said. "It takes one guy with an exotic-looking dress, a big beard or a huge headdress to say, 'Mr. member of Parliament, we will work to defeat you, or we will deliver you 10,000 votes.'

Canadian politicians do not realize that the struggle for Khalistan was extremely violent and that it has no support in India, Fatah said.

"Why would somebody come to this country and want unity of Canada but the breakup of India? Does any politician have the guts to ask these Khalistanis, 'What is it that you are looking for that you didn't find in the bloodbath of 1947, when India was first divided?'"

Go to the Top

World »

Swat Valley victory over Taliban likely in 2-3 days: Pakistani official
Pakistan's defence minister says a month-long government offensive againt Taliban fighters in the Swat Valley could be over in two or three days.
Bondholders accept deal as GM prepares for bankruptcy Video
A majority of General Motors bondholders accepted a sweetened deal to swap the company's $27-billion debt for equity, a day before the automaker was expected to enter bankruptcy protection.
German states approve Opel funding in deal with Magna
Two German states on Sunday agreed to support a bridge loan for General Motors Corp.'s Opel unit, putting the final touches on a deal for Canada's Magna International Inc. to acquire the automaker.
more »

Canada »

New border rules create 'invisible Berlin Wall': mayor
New U.S. rules on cross-border travel that take effect Monday represent a "heightened militarization" that will hurt the traditionally close relationship between border communities, the mayor of Sarnia, Ont., says. Mike Bradley was responding to the new requirement that travellers carry a secure document to enter the U.S. by land.
Law to let terror victims sue in Canadian courts, Harper says Video
The federal government is about to introduce legislation that will allow victims of terrorism to sue perpetrators in Canadian courts, Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Sunday.
100 Mile House fire contained: officials
An evacuation order has been lifted in B.C.'s central Interior now that a blaze near 100 Mile House is under control.
more »

Health »

$22M for upgrades to McMaster reactor, more medical isotopes Video
Ontario and the federal government will give McMaster University $22 million, some of it to help produce medical isotopes, Industry Minister Tony Clement said Friday.
Quebec re-examining breast cancer study Video
Medical specialists are double-checking a new study indicating as many as 30 per cent of breast cancer tests conducted in Quebec may have produced faulty results. "I think that it was done properly, but I'm wondering if their findings can be applied to all pathology testing in Quebec," Health Minister Yves Bolduc said Saturday.
Type 1 diabetes projected to double in young European children
The number of European children under the age of five with Type 1 diabetes could double by 2020, a rapid increase that points to environmental factors, researchers say.
more »

Arts & Entertainment »

Study lights into Simpsons for smoking scenes
One of TV's most enduring cartoon series, The Simpsons, may cause children to consider smoking because of its many scenes depicting the habit, according to a new study.
Scottish artist's rendering of a nude Madonna with Guy fails to sell
A painting of pop star Madonna portrayed nude in bed with her ex-husband Guy Ritchie has failed to sell at an auction in Scotland.
Susan Boyle dreamed a dream but finishes second to dance group Video
Susan Boyle, the Scottish singing sensation, sang I Dreamed A Dream from the musical Les Miserables in the finals of Britain's Got Talent and ended up in second place.
more »

Technology & Science »

Soyuz carrying Canadian astronaut docks with space station Video
Canadian astronaut Robert Thirsk's six-month stay at the International Space Station began Friday morning, after the Russian spaceship carrying him and two other astronauts from Earth docked at the orbiting platform.
Obama setting up better security for computers Video
U.S. President Barack Obama says he will soon pick the person he wants to head a new office of cyber security, saying America has for too long failed to adequately protect the security of its computer networks.
Back in the U.K.: Beavers make controversial return
Eleven beavers have been reintroduced into the Scottish wilderness after an absence of nearly 500 years. Three families consisting of 11 animals were transported from Norway and released in Argyll, Scotland on Friday as part of a controversial reintroduction program.
more »

Money »

Bondholders accept deal as GM prepares for bankruptcy Video
A majority of General Motors bondholders accepted a sweetened deal to swap the company's $27-billion debt for equity, a day before the automaker was expected to enter bankruptcy protection.
German states approve Opel funding in deal with Magna
Two German states on Sunday agreed to support a bridge loan for General Motors Corp.'s Opel unit, putting the final touches on a deal for Canada's Magna International Inc. to acquire the automaker.
Loonie soars 8 cents in May, finance minister concerned Video
The Canadian dollar jumped 1.90 cents to 91.60 cents US on Friday, a run-up of about eight cents since the beginning of May.
more »

Consumer Life »

New border rules create 'invisible Berlin Wall': mayor
New U.S. rules on cross-border travel that take effect Monday represent a "heightened militarization" that will hurt the traditionally close relationship between border communities, the mayor of Sarnia, Ont., says. Mike Bradley was responding to the new requirement that travellers carry a secure document to enter the U.S. by land.
Follow Canada's lead on cigarette warnings, says WHO
The World Health Organization has urged world governments to take a leaf out of Canada's book and mandate that cigarette packages should include images of sickness and suffering caused by tobacco, along with written warnings, the organization said Friday.
Caffeinated chewing gum risky for children, doctors warn
A teenage boy was hospitalized with caffeine intoxication after chewing stimulant gum, say Italian doctors who warn the risk to children is high if the readily available products are used excessively.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Stars name Nieuwendyk as new GM
The Dallas Stars have named former NHL forward Joe Nieuwendyk their new general manager, while reassigning former co-GMs Brett Hull and Les Jackson to other positions in the organization.
Jays' bats can't handle Red Sox's Lester
Boston lefty Jon Lester had his way with the Blue Jays on Sunday as his Red Sox defeated Toronto 8-2 to avoid being swept in the three-game series at the Rogers Centre.
Red Wings' Datsyuk, Draper still out of lineup
Pavel Datsyuk and Kris Draper will remain out of the Detroit Red Wings' lineup ahead of Sunday's Game 2 of their Stanley Cup final versus the Pittsburgh Penguins (CBC, CBCSports.ca, 8 p.m. ET).
more »