한국   대만   중국   일본 
HDTV Magazine Articles: Ed's View - SHDTV (Part Duo)
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20070928115039/http://www.hdtvmagazine.com/articles/2007/08/eds_view_shdtv_1.php
HDTV Magazine   (Not logged in)   Sign In   |   Register   |   Help Help
Free Daily HD Program Listing
 
Receive instant notification of new articles. Register Now and/or Modify your subscription profile to receive notification of new HDTV Magazine Articles via email as soon as they are published.
Digg This Ed's View - SHDTV (Part Duo)
By Ed Milbourn on August 14, 2007
Add to NewsvineNewsvine Add to Del.icio.usDel.icio.us Save ArticleSave Email ArticleEmail Print ArticlePrint


advertisement

By the end of 2007 more than 5000 North American movie screens will be capable of showing digitally distributed motion pictures, some of which are produced in 3D. The distribution medium, however, remains mechanical, i.e. the actual digital data are stored as encrypted files on hard discs. Downloading of the files via satellite has been successfully demonstrated internationally, and undoubtedly will replace the ferrying of hard drives soon.

The key to this high quality, economical motion picture distribution system is the establishment in 2002 of the Digital Cinema Initiative (DCI) specification by the seven giant motion picture studios - Disney, Fox, MGM, Paramount, Sony, Universal and Warner. In short, the DCI standard is Super High Definition Television - SHDTV. Now, this same consortium plus additional key players is studying ways to commercially expand DCI applications closer to the consumer marketplace - not only for newly released motion pictures and documentaries, but also for live television events, some produced in 3D.

The most straightforward economic model being considered by the DCI group involves the formation of a private distribution entity wholly owned by the seven (plus) DCI partners. SHDTV content would be distributed via satellite to three venue groups: private (home) installations, "small" venue theaters, and traditional theaters that have digital capability. Content packages available to each venue group would be different. Five "channels" would be offered initially, with expansion capability to ten simultaneous SHDTV programs. Private venues would select and purchase content using a subscription/PPV model, similar to the PPV models being offered by DBS satellite and Cable. Video-on-Demand (VOD) is not being considered.

Receiving hardware for the private installations would be tightly controlled. I am not sure what that means, but clearly the implication is that equipment would be offered only through licensed home theater installation outlets. Lease or lease-to-buy, or buy packages are contemplated. Obviously, this business paradigm is not intended to follow a mass-market CE product model, nor (I was asked to emphasize) is it not intended to replace, but to augment, our present terrestrial DBS and Cable HDTV ATSC based distribution systems.

Technically, as implied, the described SHDTV system is based on a subset of the presently deployed DCI specifications. Essentially, most all system components are in the final states of design or are in-place except the electronic link i.e. the satellites themselves and the wideband RF receiver systems. Transponder spectrum "slots" are not a problem, but the system is a bandwidth "hog." There is nothing economical about it, nor is there intended to be.

After analyzing an outline of the technical specifications available to me and doing some grade school mathematical extrapolations, the absolute value of 15 appears to be a good "paper napkin" approximation of costs, capability and technical demands. That is, simply multiplying or dividing by 15 will give a reasonable estimate of the techno-economic demands of SHDTV. Here is a summary of the contemplated technical specifications:

Resolution
The SHDTV resolution is 4096 x 2160 pixels at 24fps.
The highest resolution of the ATSC HDTV system is 1920 x 1080 pixels at 30fps; therefore, SHDTV has roughly four times the resolution (sometimes called 4K) as HDTV.

Aspect Ratio
The aspect ratio is 1.89:1. Further, the 4x structure will support 2.39:1 with bars. Our present HDTV aspect ratio is 1.77:1.

Compression
The no-loss version of MJPEG 2000 is employed.
This is a very inefficient, but very high quality compression system. Essentially, each frame is individually compressed, eliminating motion estimating artifacts present in MPEG. Also, bit errors translate into resolution errors, not blocking artifacts as with MPEG.

Pixel Sampling
SHDTV employs 16 bits/color (48 bits/pixel) image sampling.
Present HDTV imagers used for ATSC rarely sample above 24 bits/pixel. The higher the image sampling rate, the greater gamut (depth) of color available.

Video Compressed Payload Bit-rate
The RF link supports a streaming payload of 250 Mbits/second.
This is approximately 13 times the ATSC HDTV payload bit-rate.

Audio
An uncompressed, 8 channels, 24 bits/sample, 48 kHz sampling rate system is employed.
This provides "no compromise" CD quality audio. There is no acoustical specification, only recommendations for each venue group.

Security
The security system is based on IP delivered keys, metadata and conditional access using payload synchronized encrypted FTP sites.
This is not part of the present DCI specification which is designed for file transfer, not streaming. (Also, I'm not sure they didn't make this up, as I have no idea how it could operate.)

3D System
DCI does not specify a 3D system per se, but probably the Real D solution will be employed.

Will this all work? Technically, of course it will. Commercially, I obviously believe so, although there is a very high lawyer to engineer ratio in play. But when one considers that the "Hollywood" content moguls with the vast collective monitory resources available to them are driving this concept, it will happen.
Want a preview? Simply find one of the growing number of theaters showing digital movies and have a peak.

Ed


Posted by Ed Milbourn , August 14, 2007 10:33 AM

Reader Commentary

See Forum Topic : Ed's View - SHDTV (Part Duo) (0 replies)

Related Articles

Sep 19, 10:09AM IPTV Part 1 - Read the Fine Print (Rodolfo La Maestra)
Sep 13, 7:09AM CinemaScope™ HDHT Part 4 - Budgeting for the Project (Rodolfo La Maestra)
Sep 6, 5:09AM Mobile DTV Reception - Advanced-Vestigial Side-Band (A-VSB) - Impact Analysis (Rodolfo La Maestra)
Sep 3, 5:09AM Mobile DTV Reception - Advanced-Vestigial Side-Band (A-VSB) - The Implementation (Rodolfo La Maestra)
Aug 23, 12:08PM Mobile DTV Reception - Advanced-Vestigial Side-Band (A-VSB) - Bandwidth Requirements (Rodolfo La Maestra)

More from Ed Milbourn

Jul 12, 5:08pm Ed's View - SHDTV
Jun 1, 8:35am Ed's View - A New Light
Apr 12, 12:23pm Ed's View - Mobile Digital Television (MDT) This is a Winner
Mar 21, 11:02am Ed's View - HDTV All the Time - The Amazing UMP
Jan 30, 12:09pm Ed's View - 3DTV - Why Not Glasses?

About Ed Milbourn:

After graduating from Purdue University with degrees in Electrical Engineering and Industrial Education in 1961 and 1963 respectively, Ed Milbourn joined the RCA Home Entertainment Division in 1963. During his thirty-eight year career with RCA (later GE and Thomson multimedia), Mr. Milbourn held the positions of Field Service Engineer, Manager of Technical Training and Manager of Sales Training. In 1987, he joined Thomson's Product Management group as Manager of Advanced Television Systems Planning, with responsibilities including Digital Television and High Definition Television Product Management. Mr. Milbourn retired from Thomson multimedia in December 2001, and is now a Consumer Electronics Industry consultant.