A "Dr. Hutton" led a
Dutch Reformed
congregation on "Washington Square".
[1]
This church was built in 1837,
[2]
and Dr. Mancius S. Hutton retired from it c. 1879.
[3]
The
New York Public Library
marks the images as from a collection that covers 1858?1925, so the image is from 1858?1879.
[4]