British savoury pie
Steak and kidney pie
![](//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c6/Steak_and_kidney_pie.jpg/250px-Steak_and_kidney_pie.jpg) A steak and kidney pie, as served in a
pub
|
Type
| Savoury pie
|
---|
Place of origin
| Britain
|
---|
Serving temperature
| Hot
|
---|
Main ingredients
| |
---|
|
Steak and kidney pie
is a popular British dish. It is a savoury pie filled principally with a mixture of diced
beef
, diced
kidney
(which may be
beef
,
lamb
,
veal
, or
pork
) and
onion
. Its contents are generally similar to those of
steak and kidney puddings
.
History and ingredients
[
edit
]
In modern times the fillings of steak and kidney pies and
steak and kidney puddings
are generally identical,
[1]
but until the mid-19th century the norms were steak puddings and kidney pies.
[2]
[n 1]
Bell's Life in London and Sporting Chronicle
, 1826, records a large dish of kidney pies in the window of a baker near
Smithfield
,
[4]
and ten years later a kidney-pie stand outside what is now the
Old Vic
, emitting sparks every time the vendor opened his portable oven to hand a hot kidney pie to a customer.
[5]
"Rump Steak and Kidney Pie" was served in a
Liverpool
restaurant in 1847,
[6]
and in 1863 a
Birmingham
establishment offered "Beef Steak and Kidney Pie".
[7]
But until the 1870s kidney pies are far more frequently mentioned in the newspapers, including one thrown at a policeman during an affray in
Knightsbridge
in 1862,
[8]
and an assault case in
Lambeth
in 1867 when a customer attacked a waitress for bringing her a beef pie instead of a kidney one.
[9]
By the mid-1870s steak and kidney pies were as often mentioned as kidney ones. Both appeared in verse of the period:
You say you are too sad to eat!
Just hand your plate and try
This steak and kidney pie, my love?
This steak and kidney pie.
From
Fun
, 1875
[10]
I've eaten as much as a man could eat,
I've gone through a very remarkable feat;
From the twopenny tart to the kidney pie,
I've swallowed as much as I could, have I.
From
The Zoo
(1875), by
B. C. Stephenson
and
Arthur Sullivan
[11]
According to the cookery writer
Jane Grigson
, the first published recipe for the combination of steak and kidney was in 1859 in
Mrs Beeton
's
Household Management
.
[12]
[n 2]
Beeton used it in a
pudding
rather than a pie. She had been sent the recipe by a correspondent in
Sussex
in south-east England, and Grigson speculates that it was until then a regional dish, unfamiliar to cooks in other parts of Britain.
[12]
Beeton suggested that steak and kidney could be "very much enriched" by the addition of mushrooms or oysters.
[13]
In those days oysters were the cheaper of the two: mushroom cultivation was still in its infancy in Europe and oysters were still commonplace.
[12]
In the following century
Dorothy Hartley
(1954) recommended the use of black-gilled mushrooms rather than oysters, because long cooking is "apt to make [oysters] go hard".
[1]
[n 3]
Neither Beeton nor Hartley specified the type of animal from which the kidneys were to be used in a steak and kidney recipe. Grigson (1974) calls for either veal or ox kidney,
[12]
as does
Marcus Wareing
.
[14]
Other cooks of modern times have variously specified lamb or sheep kidney (
Marguerite Patten
,
Nigella Lawson
and
John Torode
),
[15]
ox kidney (
Mary Berry
,
Delia Smith
and
Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall
),
[16]
veal kidney (
Gordon Ramsay
),
[17]
either pork or lamb (
Jamie Oliver
),
[18]
and either ox, lamb or veal kidneys (
Gary Rhodes
).
[19]
Cooking and variations
[
edit
]
Round steak and kidney pie
Some versions are full, or "double-crust", pies, in which the cooking dish is lined with pastry before the meat mixture is added, after which a pastry top is put over it.
[20]
In other versions the meat is put straight into the dish, with only a pastry lid.
[21]
In either case, a
pie funnel
is often used to stop the top crust sinking into the meat mixture during baking.
[22]
Some recipes call for
puff pastry
; others for
shortcrust
.
[21]
In some the meat is cooked before going into the pie;
[23]
in others it goes in raw.
[1]
In addition to the steak and kidney, the filling typically contains carrots and onions, and is cooked in one or more of beef stock, red wine and
stout
.
[24]
The steak and kidney pie is found in numerous regional variants. In the
West Country
clotted or double cream may be poured into the pie through a hole in the pastry topping just before serving.
[25]
The Ormidale pie from the
Scottish Highlands
is flavoured with a teaspoon each of
Worcestershire sauce
, vinegar and tomato sauce.
[25]
In
East Yorkshire
sliced potatoes are substituted for kidneys and the dish is called meat and pot pie.
[25]
In the English Midlands, Northern England and Scotland oysters or mushrooms or both are often added; in Scotland this variant is known as Musselburgh pie.
[25]
Popular culture
[
edit
]
Among the various vernacular names for steak and kidney pie are Kate and Sidney pie, snake and kiddy pie, and snake and pygmy pie.
[26]
Eric Partridge
dates the first of these to around 1880.
[27]
A substantial part of the plot of
P. G. Wodehouse
's 1963 comic novel
Stiff Upper Lip, Jeeves
hinges on the disruptive allure of a magnificent steak and kidney pie for a young man whose fiancee has decreed that he must turn vegetarian.
[28]
See also
[
edit
]
Notes, references and sources
[
edit
]
Notes
[
edit
]
- ^
Elizabeth David
came across a 17th-century recipe for a "Steake Pye", but unlike modern pies it had no lid, and contained a mixture of beef and mutton.
[3]
- ^
The work was published in book form in 1861, but had appeared as a part-work over the previous two years.
[12]
- ^
Hartley suggested that if seafood were wanted in a steak-and-kidney mix, cockles would be preferable to oysters.
[1]
References
[
edit
]
- ^
a
b
c
d
Hartley, pp. 87?88
- ^
Davidson, p. 754
- ^
David, p. 145
- ^
"Jack Scroggins and the Kidney Pie",
Bell's Life in London and Sporting Chronicle
, 12 November 1826, p. 3
- ^
"the Streets at Night",
Bell's Life in London and Sporting Chronicle
, 17 January 1836, p. 3
- ^
"Cafe Francais et Restaurant",
The Albion
, 25 October 1847, p. 5,
- ^
"Benson's",
Birmingham Daily Post
, 17 February 1863, p. 1
- ^
"Local Police",
West Middlesex Advertiser
, 1 November 1862, p. 3
- ^
"Police Intelligence",
The Sun
, 30 March 1867
- ^
"Tiffin'",
The Star
, 24 July 1875, p. 3
- ^
The Zoo
Archived
2021-10-07 at the
Wayback Machine
, Gilbert and Sullivan Archive, p. 7. Retrieved 2 May 2022
- ^
a
b
c
d
e
Grigson, p. 243
- ^
Beeton, pp. 281?282
- ^
"Steak and Kidney Pudding by Marcus Wareing"
Archived
12 May 2021 at the
Wayback Machine
,
The Caterer
, 11 September 2006
- ^
Patten, p. 156; Lawson, Nigella.
"Steak and kidney pudding"
Archived
27 November 2021 at the
Wayback Machine
, Nigella Recipes. Retrieved 1 May 2022; and Torode, p. 122
- ^
Berry, p. 65; Smith, Delia.
"Mum's Steak and Kidney Plate Pie"
Archived
20 March 2022 at the
Wayback Machine
, DeliaOnline. Retrieved 1 May 2022; and Fearnley-Whittingstall, p. 53
- ^
Ramsay, p. 138
- ^
Oliver, Jamie.
"Steak and kidney pudding"
Archived
2 May 2022 at the
Wayback Machine
, jamieoliver.com. Retrieved 1 May 2022
- ^
Rhodes (1994), p. 122 and (1997), p. 118
- ^
Berry, pp. 184?185
- ^
a
b
Martin, p. 53
- ^
Willan, p. 91
- ^
Smith, Delia.
"Mum's Steak and Kidney Plate Pie"
Archived
20 March 2022 at the
Wayback Machine
, DeliaOnline. Retrieved 1 May 2022
- ^
Cloake, Felicity.
"How to cook the perfect steak and kidney pudding"
Archived
31 March 2022 at the
Wayback Machine
,
The Guardian
, 1 March 2012
- ^
a
b
c
d
Boyd pp. 321?322
- ^
Icons.org - steak-kidney-pie
Archived
17 December 2006 at the
Wayback Machine
- ^
Partridge, p. 502
- ^
Wodehouse, pp. 50, 52, 56, 73?74 and 98
Sources
[
edit
]
- Beeton, Isabella
(1861).
The Book of Household Management
. London: S.O. Beeton.
OCLC
1045333327
.
- Berry, Mary
(2006).
Mary Berry's Christmas Collection
. London: Headline.
ISBN
978-0-7553-1562-8
.
- Boyd, Lizzie (1977).
British Cookery: A Complete Guide to Culinary Practice in the British Isles
. London: Croom Helm.
ISBN
978-0-85664-851-9
.
- David, Elizabeth
(2000) [1970].
Spices, Salt and Aromatics in the English Kitchen
. London: Grub Street.
ISBN
978-1-902304-66-3
.
- Davidson, Alan
(1999).
The Oxford Companion to Food
. Oxford:
Oxford University Press
.
ISBN
0-19-211579-0
.
- Fearnley-Whittingstall, Hugh
(2005).
The River Cottage Year
. London: Hodder & Stoughton.
ISBN
978-0-340-82822-9
.
- Grigson, Jane
(1992).
English Food
. London: Ebury Press.
ISBN
978-0-09-177043-3
.
- Hartley, Dorothy
(1999) [1954].
Food in England
. London: Macdonald and Jane's.
ISBN
978-1-85605-497-3
.
- Martin, James
(2008).
James Martin's Great British Dinners
. London: Mitchell Beazley.
ISBN
978-1-84533-582-3
.
- Partridge, Eric
(2009).
A Dictionary of Historical Slang
. London: Penguin.
ISBN
978-0-14-051046-1
.
- Patten, Marguerite
(1958).
Learning to Cook with Marguerite Patten
. London: Pan.
ISBN
978-0-330-23025-4
.
- Ramsay, Gordon
(2009).
Gordon Ramsay's Great British Pub Food
. London: HarperCollins.
ISBN
978-0-00-728982-0
.
- Rhodes, Gary
(1994).
Rhodes Around Britain
. London: BBC Books.
ISBN
978-0-563-36440-5
.
- Rhodes, Gary (1997).
Fabulous Food
. London: BBC Books.
ISBN
978-0-563-38385-7
.
- Torode, John
(2008).
Beef
. London: Quadrille.
ISBN
978-1-84400-690-8
.
- Willan, Anne
(1979).
Grand Diplome Cooking Course
. Danbury: Grolier.
OCLC
1035310033
.
- Wodehouse, P. G.
(1966) [1963].
Stiff Upper Lip, Jeeves
. London: Penguin.
ISBN
978-0-14-002479-1
.
See also
[
edit
]
External links
[
edit
]
|
---|
Sweet
| |
---|
Savoury
| |
---|
Manufacturers
| |
---|