An edit that makes a superficial difference
Wikipedia information page
| This page in a nutshell:
- Checking the
minor edit
box signifies that the current and previous versions differ only superficially (typographical corrections, etc.), in a way that no editor would be expected to regard as disputable.
- Any edit that changes the
meaning
of an article is not a minor edit, even if the edit concerns a single word, and it is improper to mark such an edit as minor.
|
A check to the
minor edit
box signifies that only superficial differences exist between the current and previous versions. Examples include
typographical corrections
, corrections of minor formatting errors, and reversion of obvious
vandalism
. A
minor edit
is one that the editor believes requires no review and could never be the subject of a dispute. An edit of this kind is marked in its page's
revision history
with a lowercase, bolded "m" character (
m
).
By contrast, a major edit should be reviewed for its acceptability by all concerned editors. Any change that affects the
meaning
of an article is not minor, even if it concerns a single word.
Because editors may choose to ignore minor edits when reviewing
recent changes
, the distinction between major and minor edits is significant. Logged-in users can set their
preferences
not to display minor edits. If there is any chance that another editor might dispute a change, the edit should not be marked as minor. (If an editor considers a change to be minor yet conceivably controversial, one option is to include the word "minor" in the
edit summary
without ticking the "minor edit" box.)
Users who are not
logged in
to Wikipedia are not permitted to mark changes as minor because of the potential for vandalism.
[a]
The ability to mark changes as minor is
among the many reasons to create and use an account
on Wikipedia to edit.
A good rule of thumb is that edits consisting
solely
of spelling corrections, formatting changes, or rearrangement of text without modification of the content should be flagged as minor edits.
How to mark an edit as minor
Below the edit summary field, there is a checkbox that says, "This is a
minor edit
". Most browsers support
access keys
(keyboard shortcuts); the access key for the minor edit checkbox is
i
. You can mark and save an edit quickly by using the access keys for minor edit (
i
) and save (
s
).
When filling in the edit summary, you may also press
Tab ?
+
Space
to check the minor edit box quickly.
What to mark as minor changes
- Spelling, grammatical, and punctuation corrections, for example "
Condoleeza Rice
" to "
Condoleezza Rice
"
- Simple formatting (e.g., capitalization, or properly adding
italics
to non-English words, like
folie des grandeurs
, or titles of certain works, like
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer
)
- Formatting that does not change the meaning of the page (e.g., moving a picture, splitting one paragraph into two?where this is not contentious)
- Fixing layout errors
- Adding or correcting
wikilinks
, or fixing broken external links and references already present in the article
- Removing obvious vandalism
What
not
to mark as minor changes
- Adding or removing content in an article
- Adding or removing visible
tags
or other templates in an article
- Adding or removing
references
/citations,
external links
, or
categories
in an article
- Adding comments to a
talk page
or other discussion
Things to remember
- Marking a major change as a minor one is considered poor etiquette, especially if the change involves the deletion of some text.
- Consequently, if you are in doubt about whether an edit is minor or not, it is
always
safer
not
to mark it as minor.
- Reverting
a page is not likely to be considered minor under most circumstances. When the status of a page is disputed, and particularly if an edit war is brewing, then it is better not to mark
any
edit as minor. Reverting blatant vandalism is an exception to this rule.
- If you
accidentally
mark an edit as minor when it was, in fact, a major edit, you should make a second edit, or
dummy edit
, noting in the dummy's
edit summary
that the previous edit was major. As a trivial edit to be made for this purpose, just
opening the edit box and saving
(i.e., changing nothing) will not work. In addition, certain changes will not work if they do not affect the presentation of the page in
HTML
, such as adding a blank space at the end of a line or a blank line at the end of the page; in these cases, the edit is cancelled and the edit summary discarded. However, one can, for example, add an extra space between two words. This will be preserved in the wikitext and recorded as a change, although it will not change the page's appearance when rendered. Do not mark the dummy edit as minor.
- It may be worth communicating any disagreement about what is minor via Talk or a message to the contributor, being careful to avoid a flame war. There is a grey area, and many contributors will appreciate feedback on whether they have got it right.
- Marking your change as minor affects how it displays in some
editors' watchlists
. If, for example, you mark your talk page comments as "minor", then fewer editors are likely to notice your comment.
- The designation of a change as minor or major is not a reflection of how much work went into making the change. For instance, even if you spent several hours finding and resolving problems with the formatting of references, the change would still be
called
minor. Editors should not feel that marking a change as minor devalues their effort.
- The use of this feature is optional.
Exceptions
Administrators
and
rollbackers
can semi-automatically revert the edits of the last editor of a page; all such
rollback
reversions are marked as minor by the wiki software. The intended use of the rollback feature is for cases of vandalism, where the act of reverting any vandalism should be considered minor (and can be ignored in the recent changes list).
Additionally,
bot accounts
usually mark their edits as minor in addition to the "bot" flag.
See also
Notes