From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Philosophical principle relating to causality
The
exclusion principle
is a
philosophical
principle that states:
- If an
event
e
causes
event
e*
, then there is no event
e#
such that
e#
is
non-supervenient
on
e
and
e#
causes
e*
.
In physicalism
[
edit
]
The exclusion principle is most commonly applied when one poses this scenario: One usually considers the desire to lift one's arm as a mental event, and the lifting of one's arm a physical event. According to the exclusion principle, there must be no event that does not supervene on
e
while causing
e*
. To show this better, substitute "
the desire to lift one's arm
" for "
e
", and "
one to lift their arm
" for "
e*
".
- If
the desire to lift one's arm
causes
one to lift their arm
, then there is no event such that it is non-supervenient on
the desire to lift one's arm
and it causes
one to lift their arm
.
This is interpreted as meaning that mental events supervene upon the physical. However, some philosophers do not accept this principle, and accept
epiphenomenalism
, which states that mental events are caused by physical events, but physical events are not caused by mental events (called
causal impotence
). However, If
e#
does not cause
e
, then there is no way to verify that
e*
exists. Yet, this debate has not been settled in the philosophical community.
External links
[
edit
]