35th edition of Major League Baseball's American League Championship Series
The
2004 American League Championship Series
was the
Major League Baseball
playoff series
deciding the 2004 season
American League
champion earning the privilege to play in the
2004 World Series
. A rematch of the
2003 American League Championship Series
, it was played between the
Boston Red Sox
, who had won the AL
wild card
and defeated the
Anaheim Angels
in the
American League Division Series
, and the
New York Yankees
, who had won the
AL East
with the best record in the AL and defeated the
Minnesota Twins
. The Red Sox became the first (and to date only) team in MLB history to come back from a
3?0 series deficit
to win a best-of-seven series. Prior to the 2004 ALCS, no MLB team had so much as forced a Game 7 under those circumstances ? and only one team since 2004 has been able to do so (that team being the 2020
Houston Astros
, who after being down 3?0 in that year's
ALCS
went on to lose in seven games to the
Tampa Bay Rays
).
In Game 1, Yankees pitcher
Mike Mussina
pitched a
perfect game
through six innings, while the Red Sox recovered from an eight-run deficit to close within one run before the Yankees eventually won.
[1]
A
home run
by
John Olerud
helped the Yankees win Game 2. The Yankees gathered 22
hits
in Game 3 on their way to an easy win.
[2]
The Yankees led Game 4 by one run in the ninth inning, but a steal of
second base
by Red Sox
base runner
Dave Roberts
and a
single
by
Bill Mueller
off Yankees closer
Mariano Rivera
tied the game.
[3]
David Ortiz
hit a homerun in extra innings for the Red Sox win. In Game 5, Ortiz hit a 14th inning walk-off single for the Red Sox.
Curt Schilling
pitched seven innings in Game 6 for the Red Sox, during which time his right foot sock became soaked in blood due to an ankle injury.
[4]
Game 7 featured the Red Sox paying back New York for their Game 3 blowout with a dominant performance on the road, anchored by
Derek Lowe
and bolstered by two
Johnny Damon
home runs including an upper deck
grand slam
. Manny Ramirez was named the
Most Valuable Player
of the series.
[5]
The Red Sox went on to sweep the
St. Louis Cardinals
in the
World Series
, winning their first World Series championship in
86 years
and ending the so-called
Curse of the Bambino
.
Route to the series
[
edit
]
Boston Red Sox
[
edit
]
The Red Sox ended their 2003 season in the previous American League Championship Series with a game seven loss to the Yankees, on a
walk-off home run
by Yankees
third baseman
Aaron Boone
in the bottom of the 11th inning.
[6]
During the offseason, they traded
Casey Fossum
,
Brandon Lyon
,
Jorge de la Rosa
, and a minor leaguer to the
Arizona Diamondbacks
for ace starting pitcher
Curt Schilling
.
[7]
Manager
Grady Little
was also fired and replaced with
Terry Francona
due to poor decisions that Little made during the previous season's playoffs.
[8]
The Red Sox also signed a closing pitcher,
Keith Foulke
, to a three-year contract.
[9]
Going into the all-star break, the Red Sox were seven games behind the Yankees for the division lead with a record of 48?38, but led the wild card.
[10]
In an attempt to improve the team and solidify a playoff decision and in anticipation for a showdown against the New York Yankees,
[11]
general manager
Theo Epstein
traded well-liked shortstop
Nomar Garciaparra
to the
Chicago Cubs
in exchange for
first baseman
Doug Mientkiewicz
and shortstop
Orlando Cabrera
in a four-team deal on the trading deadline (July 31).
[11]
[12]
The team fell behind up to
10
+
1
⁄
2
games in the division during the month of August, but managed to come back in September to within two games.
[10]
However, the Yankees held strong and won the division, finishing three games ahead of the Red Sox.
[13]
The Red Sox won the AL Wild Card (the best record among three second-place teams) to obtain a spot in the playoffs.
[13]
Entering the postseason, first baseman
Kevin Millar
was asked to compare the team with the previous season's team, to which he responded, "I'm pretty sure we're five outs better than last year." It was a reference to the
2003 American League Championship Series
, in which the Red Sox held a 5?2 lead over the Yankees with one out in the eighth inning of Game 7, only to blow the lead and lose the series.
The Red Sox would sweep the
Anaheim Angels
in three games, but at a cost. In the first game of the series, Schilling would be hurt by a line drive hit off his foot, leaving the rest of his postseason play in doubt.
New York Yankees
[
edit
]
The 2004 Yankees began the season in
Tokyo
with a split against the Rays. Playing a much-anticipated game against the Red Sox, the team lost the game 6?2 and 6 out of the first 7 games to their rivals. After falling as many as
4
+
1
⁄
2
games behind the Red Sox on April 25, the team would make up the deficit in less than 2 weeks, including an 8-game win streak. By the end of June, they had a commanding
8
+
1
⁄
2
game lead in the AL East over the Sox after sweeping them with a dramatic 5?4 walk-off 13-inning victory. After the All-Star break, the Yankees traded
Jose Contreras
to the White Sox for
Esteban Loaiza
. Contreras was signed away from the Red Sox before the
2003 season
, but he failed to live up to expectations. With a
10
+
1
⁄
2
game lead in the second week of August, the team struggled and watched their lead dwindle to only
2
+
1
⁄
2
games on September 3. The team held off the Red Sox to claim the division and set up a playoff rematch with the
Twins
. The results were pretty much the same, as the Yankees took the Division Series in 4 games, setting up the rematch.
Series build-up
[
edit
]
The Red Sox and Yankees had met 45 times in the previous two years, with Boston holding a 23?22 lead. The Red Sox held an 11?8 advantage over New York in 2004, but eight of the games were decided in one of the teams' final at-bats. Boston outscored New York, 106?105.
[14]
and this was the fifth time that the two teams were on the doorstep of a World Series, with the Yankees winning the previous four, in
1949
,
1978
,
1999
, and
2003
.
[14]
The Series was widely anticipated, especially given the outcome of the
previous October
, when the Yankees beat the Red Sox in seven games when
Aaron Boone
hit the home run off of
Tim Wakefield
in the bottom of the 11th inning to send the Yankees to the
World Series
.
[15]
[16]
Yankees General Manager
Brian Cashman
said that "the two teams in the American League facing each other in this series are the two best teams, period."
[17]
Fox
commentator
Joe Buck
said as the series began: "Well, it's hard to believe, it was almost exactly one year ago tonight that Aaron Boone hit that 11th inning home run to beat the Red Sox...yet for some reason it seemed predetermined that we would be right back here a year later for a rematch of sort."
[18]
[19]
Dan Shaughnessy
of
The Boston Globe
wrote that "one year after they (Yankees) jousted to the (Sox's) finish in the Bronx last October in an epic seventh game that appeared to take the clash to its zenith they go at it again..."
[20]
In this series,
Alex Rodriguez
seemed to answer the Sox' acquisition of
Curt Schilling
, as the two veteran stars faced each other, "wearing the uniforms of the ancient rivals in an October game..."
[20]
Yankees pitcher
Mike Mussina
summed up the build-up: "This is what everyone was hoping for...It's a rematch of last year, with the best two teams in the American League."
[20]
The New York Times
said that this was the showdown the Yankees anticipated the entire season, while the Red Sox craved it an entire year. This was the reason why the Red Sox fired
Grady Little
, traded
Nomar Garciaparra
, and added Curt Schilling.
[11]
Outfielder
Johnny Damon
said of Boone's home run: "If we do advance to the World Series and win, it's a better story that we went through New York. We needed to get back here. This is where a lot of hearts were broken, and we're in a perfect seat to stop the hurting."
[11]
The Red Sox'
Theo Epstein
agreed, saying "Now that it's here, we can admit that if we're able to win a World Series and go through New York along the way, it will mean that much more."
[21]
Initially, Game 4
[22]
was scheduled for the afternoon.
[23]
However,
MLB Commissioner
Bud Selig
had moved the starting time of Game 4
[22]
to primetime, due to the rematch,
[24]
and Fox had a triple-header, first the
Seattle Seahawks
?
New England Patriots
game at
Gillette Stadium
at 1:00 pm ET, then Game 4 of the
NLCS
between the
St. Louis Cardinals
and
Houston Astros
at
Minute Maid Park
at 4:30 pm ET.
[23]
Summary
[
edit
]
New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox
[
edit
]
Boston won the series, 4?3.
Game
|
Date
|
Score
|
Location
|
Time
|
Attendance
|
1
|
October 12
|
Boston Red Sox ? 7,
New York Yankees
? 10
|
Yankee Stadium (I)
|
3:20
|
56,135
[25]
|
2
|
October 13
|
Boston Red Sox ? 1,
New York Yankees
? 3
|
Yankee Stadium (I)
|
3:15
|
56,136
[26]
|
3
|
October 16
|
New York Yankees
? 19, Boston Red Sox ? 8
|
Fenway Park
|
4:20
|
35,126
[27]
|
4
|
October 17
|
New York Yankees ? 4,
Boston Red Sox
? 6 (12 innings)
|
Fenway Park
|
5:02
|
34,826
[28]
|
5
|
October 18
|
New York Yankees ? 4,
Boston Red Sox
? 5 (14 innings)
|
Fenway Park
|
5:49
|
35,120
[29]
|
6
|
October 19
|
Boston Red Sox
? 4, New York Yankees ? 2
|
Yankee Stadium (I)
|
3:50
|
56,128
[30]
|
7
|
October 20
|
Boston Red Sox
? 10, New York Yankees ? 3
|
Yankee Stadium (I)
|
3:31
|
56,129
[31]
|
Game summaries
[
edit
]
Game 1
[
edit
]
Tuesday, October 12, 2004, at
Yankee Stadium (I)
in
Bronx, New York
Game 1 pitted the Red Sox's star pitcher
Curt Schilling
against Yankees ace
Mike Mussina
. Schilling entered the game with a 6?1 postseason career record, but the expected pitchers' duel quickly became a one-sided exhibition. Schilling had sustained a torn
tendon sheath
in his right ankle during Game 1 of the
American League Division Series
against the Angels, and proved to be ineffective. In the first,
Gary Sheffield
doubled with two outs before
Hideki Matsui
drove him in with a double, then Matsui scored on
Bernie Williams
's single. In the third, the Yankees loaded the bases with no outs on two singles and a walk before Matsui cleared them with a double. After moving to third on a groundout, Matsui scored on
Jorge Posada
's sacrifice fly. In the sixth,
Kenny Lofton
hit a leadoff home run off of knuckleballer
Tim Wakefield
. Sheffield doubled with two outs before scoring on a single by Matsui, giving him an ALCS record-tying five
RBIs
in the game.
Mussina, meanwhile, retired the game's first 19 Red Sox batters.
Mark Bellhorn
ended Mussina's bid for a
perfect game
with a one-out double in the seventh. After
David Ortiz
singled with two outs,
Kevin Millar
's double to left scored two runs. Millar moved to third on a passed ball before scoring on
Trot Nixon
's single.
Tanyon Sturtze
relieved Mussina and allowed a home run to
Jason Varitek
that made it 8?5 Yankees. Next inning,
Tom Gordon
allowed singles to
Bill Mueller
and
Manny Ramirez
before Ortiz's two-out triple cut the Yankees lead to 8?7. The Yankees called upon closer
Mariano Rivera
, who induced a pop out by
Kevin Millar
to end the inning. In the bottom half,
Alex Rodriguez
and Sheffield singled off of
Mike Timlin
before Williams' two-run double made it 10?7 Yankees. The Sox hit two singles in the top of the ninth inning off of Rivera, but the game ended when
Bill Mueller
grounded into a double play.
Game 2
[
edit
]
Wednesday, October 13, 2004, at
Yankee Stadium (I)
in
Bronx, New York
Game 2 featured
Pedro Martinez
of the Red Sox facing Yankees pitcher
Jon Lieber
. Again, the Yankees struck first, as
Gary Sheffield
drove in
Derek Jeter
, who walked, in the first inning. The 1?0 score held up for several innings, as Lieber and Martinez put together a classic pitchers' duel.
Martinez got himself in and out of trouble through several innings, but, shortly after making his 100th pitch of the night, walked
Jorge Posada
and allowed a
John Olerud
home run, giving New York a 3?0 lead.
Again, the Red Sox rallied.
Trot Nixon
singled to lead off the eighth off of Lieber, who was replaced by
Tom Gordon
. A double by
Jason Varitek
moved Nixon to third before
Orlando Cabrera
's RBI groundout closed the gap, 3?1. With two outs and a runner on third, however, the Yankees again turned to Rivera, who struck out
Johnny Damon
to end the inning. Rivera shut down the Red Sox in the ninth by inducing a groundout by
Mark Bellhorn
, and, after giving up a double to
Manny Ramirez
, striking out
David Ortiz
and Millar, ending the game.
Game 3
[
edit
]
Saturday, October 16, 2004, at
Fenway Park
in Boston, Massachusetts
With the series moving to
Fenway Park
, Game 3 was originally scheduled for October 15, but was postponed a day due to rain.
[32]
[33]
The starting pitchers were
Kevin Brown
for the Yankees and
Bronson Arroyo
for the
Red Sox
.
As in the first two games, the Yankees began by scoring in the first. Derek Jeter walked and scored from first on a double by Alex Rodriguez. Two batters later, Hideki Matsui hit a home run to right field, giving the Yankees a 3?0 lead. The Red Sox answered in the second inning with a leadoff walk by
Jason Varitek
and a
Trot Nixon
home run to right field. A double by Bill Mueller, an infield RBI hit by Johnny Damon (his first hit of the series), and a Derek Jeter error led to two more runs. The Red Sox led for the first time in the series, 4?3.
This lead was short-lived, as Alex Rodriguez led off the third inning with a home run over the
Green Monster
. Gary Sheffield then walked and Hideki Matsui doubled, prompting Bronson Arroyo to be replaced on the mound by
Ramiro Mendoza
, who immediately allowed a Bernie Williams RBI single and then
balked
, allowing Matsui to score from third, which gave the Yankees a 6?4 lead. The Red Sox, however, responded in the bottom of the inning, scoring two runs on an
Orlando Cabrera
bases-loaded double off Yankees reliever
Javier Vazquez
to tie the game.
In the fourth inning, the Yankees took the lead on a three-run home run to left by Gary Sheffield after a walk and hit-by-pitch. After another double by Hideki Matsui, the Red Sox put in pitcher
Tim Wakefield
, who volunteered to forgo his scheduled Game 4 start in order to preserve Boston's battered bullpen. Wakefield got Bernie Williams to pop out and then intentionally walked Jorge Posada.
Ruben Sierra
then tripled to score Matsui and Posada, giving the Yankees an 11?6 lead.
[2]
From that point on the Yankees were in total control, with the New York offense continuing to hit and score runs long into the night. In the fifth, Jeter walked with one-out before back-to-back RBI doubles by Rodriguez and Sheffield made it 13?6 Yankees. In the seventh,
Miguel Cairo
and Sheffield singled off of Wakefield, who was relieved by
Alan Embree
. Matsui's single scored a run, Williams's double scored two, and
Jorge Posada
's double scored another. The Red Sox scored their last runs of the game in the bottom of the inning off of Vazquez on
Jason Varitek
's two-run home run after a leadoff single. Matsui also hit a two-run home run in the ninth off of
Mike Myers
.
When the game was over, the Yankees had set a team record for postseason runs scored. Rodriguez, Sheffield, and Matsui had prolific hitting nights. Matsui had five hits and five RBIs, tying LCS records. He and Rodriguez both tied the postseason record for runs scored with five.
[2]
The two teams combined for 37 hits and 20 extra-base hits, both postseason records.
[2]
At four hours and 20 minutes, the contest was the longest nine-inning postseason game ever played up to that time.
[2]
Although the final score was 19?8,
Dan Shaughnessy
of
The Boston Globe
said "nineteen to eight. Why not '19?18'?"
[2]
[34]
He was referring to the Red Sox not having won a World Series since
1918
, and
demeaning chants of that year
echoed at
Yankee Stadium
.
[11]
Bob Ryan
wrote about the Red Sox in
The Boston Globe
: "They are down, 3?0, after last night's 19?8 rout, and, in this sport, that is an official death sentence. Soon it will be over, and we will spend another dreary winter lamenting this and lamenting that."
[35]
However, this would turn out to be the Yankees' last win in this series.
Game 4
[
edit
]
Sunday, October 17, 2004, at
Fenway Park
in Boston, Massachusetts
Game 4 featured Yankees pitcher
Orlando Hernandez
, the 1999 ALCS MVP against Boston's
Derek Lowe
. For the first time in the series, the Yankees did not score in the first inning. However, they eventually did score first. With two outs and nobody on in the third inning,
Derek Jeter
singled.
Alex Rodriguez
then hit a two-run home run over the
Green Monster
. This hit resembled a home run he hit in Game 3, as it also came in the third inning and went out of the park onto Lansdowne Street. This would be followed by the ball being thrown back into the outfield by fans on the Street,
Johnny Damon
tossing the ball back over the fence, and the ball once again being tossed back before being pocketed by Umpire
Joe West
.
Hernandez, who had not pitched in two weeks, cruised through the first four innings giving up just one hit and two walks. In the fifth inning, he pitched himself into a jam, walking two of the first three batters. With two men on and two out,
Orlando Cabrera
singled to right field, scoring
Bill Mueller
.
Manny Ramirez
walked to load the bases, and then
David Ortiz
hit a single to center field, scoring Cabrera and
Johnny Damon
and giving the Red Sox a 3?2 lead, only their second lead in the series.
The lead lasted less than an inning.
Hideki Matsui
hit a triple with one out in the sixth, after which
Mike Timlin
relieved Lowe.
Bernie Williams
hit an infield single to score Matsui and tie the game 3-3. After
Jorge Posada
walked, Williams attempted to advance to third on a passed ball but was thrown out by
Jason Varitek
. However,
Ruben Sierra
hit another infield single, moving Posada to third.
Tony Clark
then hit the third infield single of the inning, to score Posada and give the Yankees a 4?3 lead.
Miguel Cairo
then walked to load the bases for Jeter, but Timlin induced a groundout to escape the inning.
Massachusetts native
Tanyon Sturtze
pitched two scoreless innings in relief of Hernandez.
Mariano Rivera
, the Yankees star closer, entered the game in the eighth for a two-inning save attempt. In the ninth inning, Rivera allowed a lead-off walk to
Kevin Millar
, which ultimately turned out to be the turning point of the series.
Dave Roberts
was then chosen to pinch-run for Millar. With the Red Sox down to their final three outs, Rivera checked Roberts at first base three times before throwing a pitch to
Bill Mueller
.
On Rivera's first pitch to Mueller, the speedy Roberts
stole
second, putting himself in scoring position. Mueller's single (through Rivera and into centerfield) allowed Roberts to score, resulting in Rivera blowing the save and the game going into extra innings, tied at four runs apiece.
Both teams threatened for more runs in the 11th inning, but the game remained tied until the bottom of the 12th. Ramirez led off with a single against new pitcher
Paul Quantrill
, who had relieved
Tom Gordon
, and Ortiz hit a two-run
walk-off home run
to right field. Ortiz became the first player with two walk-off homers in the same postseason; his first capped a Red Sox sweep of the
Anaheim Angels
in the
American League Division Series
. Red Sox pitcher
Curtis Leskanic
got the win in relief after being called on to stop the Yankees' 11th inning threat and had pitched the 12th and allowed no runs.
Game 5
[
edit
]
Monday, October 18, 2004, at
Fenway Park
in Boston, Massachusetts
Game 5 began at 5:11 pm EDT on Monday, October 18, just 16 hours after Game 4 had ended. Mike Mussina led the Yankees against Boston's Pedro Martinez. The Red Sox drew first blood this time, as David Ortiz drove in a run with an RBI single after two one-out singles and Jason Varitek walked with the bases loaded in the first inning to give Boston a 2?0 lead. Bernie Williams homered in the second inning to close the gap to 2?1, a score which would hold up for several innings.
Despite seven strikeouts by Martinez, in the top of the sixth inning, Jorge Posada and Ruben Sierra singled with one out. After Miguel Cairo was hit by a pitch to load the bases, Derek Jeter cleared the bases with a double, giving the Yankees a 4?2 lead. The Red Sox threatened again in the seventh inning but came up empty. For the second straight night, however, the Yankee bullpen could not keep the lead. Ortiz led off the eighth inning with a home run off former Red Sox reliever Tom Gordon, making it a one-run game. Kevin Millar followed with a walk and was again replaced by pinch runner Dave Roberts, who went to third on Trot Nixon's single. Gordon was replaced by Mariano Rivera with the lead still intact, but Jason Varitek's sacrifice fly tied the game. The Yankees threatened in the top of the ninth when former Red Sox player Tony Clark hit a ball to deep right with two outs, but the ball took a hop over the short right-field wall for a
ground-rule double
, forcing Ruben Sierra to stop at third base, where he was stranded to set up another extra-inning marathon.
Each team got its share of base runners in extra innings. Boston's
Doug Mientkiewicz
doubled in the tenth and moved to third, but did not score. Two Red Sox led off the 11th with singles, but
Esteban Loaiza
, who had struggled since being acquired by the Yankees mid-season, came in to pitch with one out and got Orlando Cabrera to ground into a double play. Knuckleballer Tim Wakefield came on in relief once again for the Red Sox in the 12th. He allowed a single to Miguel Cairo, who went to second on a Manny Ramirez error, but Cairo was eventually stranded. In the top of the 13th, Red Sox catcher Jason Varitek, who did not normally catch for Wakefield (backup catcher Doug Mirabelli usually did) and who admitted to being poor at catching knuckleballs, allowed three
passed balls
, but the Yankees stranded runners on second and third when Sierra struck out. Loaiza pitched well over his first two innings, but, in the bottom of the 14th, Damon and Ramirez walked, bringing up Ortiz with two outs. The previous night's hero did his job again, singling to center on the 10th pitch of the at-bat to bring home Damon and setting off another celebration at Fenway. Ortiz's heroics prompted Fox TV announcer
Tim McCarver
to gush shortly afterwards, saying, "He didn't do it again, did he? Yes he did." The late inning heroics of Ortiz also gave the Red Sox fans a chance to create their own chant, "Who's your Papi?" (Ortiz being known affectionately as "Big Papi"), in rebuttal to the "Who's your daddy?" chant used by Yankees fans in reference to a quote by Pedro Martinez.
The game set the record for longest duration of a postseason game at 5 hours, 49 minutes, a record which was broken the next year by Game 4 of the
2005 National League Division Series
between the
Houston Astros
and
Atlanta Braves
, which was only one minute longer even though it was 18 innings instead of 14. The current record for longest postseason game is Game 3 of the
2018 World Series
between the Red Sox and
Los Angeles Dodgers
, which was also 18 innings but lasted seven hours and 20 minutes.
Game 5 of the
National League Championship Series
began at 8:54 pm EST on the same night and was intended to be the second part of FOX's two-game telecast. However, that game proceeded quickly and, despite starting 3 hours and 43 minutes after ALCS Game 5, ended only 24 minutes after the final pitch of this game.
This victory by the Red Sox forced a Game 6. Before this, the
1998 Atlanta Braves
and
1999 New York Mets
were the only baseball teams ever to be down 0?3 in a seven-game series and force a Game 6, but neither of those teams won that game.
Game 6
[
edit
]
"The Bloody Sock Game"
Tuesday, October 19, 2004, at
Yankee Stadium (I)
in
Bronx, New York
Game 6 was held on Tuesday, October 19 at Yankee Stadium. The starting pitchers were
Curt Schilling
of the Red Sox and
Jon Lieber
of the Yankees. Schilling pitched with a torn tendon sheath in his right ankle, which was sutured in place in an unprecedented procedure by Red Sox team doctors. The teams played the first few innings scoreless as cold, windy conditions, combined with a light drizzle, kept many hard hit balls in the field of play. Lieber, who had been brilliant in Game 2, was the first of the starters to falter, to the surprise of many given Lieber's Game 2 outing and Schilling's injured state. Lieber surrendered a two-out single to
Jason Varitek
, driving in
Kevin Millar
. Then Orlando Cabrera singled to left field and
Mark Bellhorn
, who had struggled the entire series, drove a line drive into the left field stands. The ball struck a fan in the hands in an attempted catch and dropped back onto the field, after which left field
umpire
Jim Joyce
signaled the ball to be still in play, prompting Boston manager
Terry Francona
to run onto the field and argue the ruling. The officiating crew huddled and ultimately overruled the call. Bellhorn had a three-run home run, and the Red Sox had a 4?0 lead.
Schilling, still injured from the
ALDS
and Game 1, pitched seven strong innings, allowing only one run on a
Bernie Williams
home run. To help stabilize the tendon in his ankle, Red Sox doctors had placed three
sutures
connecting the skin with ligament and deep connective tissue next to the bone, effectively creating a wall of tissue to keep the
peroneal tendon
from disrupting Schilling's pitching mechanics. Schilling was only forced to field his position once and visibly limped to first base to field the toss from Millar. Nonetheless, the Yankees did not bunt for the duration of Schilling's outing, something Joe Torre later explained as not playing out of the normal character of his team. Torre also admitted that had he known beforehand how bad the injury really was, it might have changed his mind. By the end of his performance, Schilling's white sanitary sock was partially soaked in blood, and he stated later that he was completely exhausted.
Bronson Arroyo
took the mound for Boston in the eighth and, with one out, allowed a
Miguel Cairo
double.
Derek Jeter
singled him in to close the gap to 4?2, leading up to the series' most controversial play.
Alex Rodriguez
grounded a ball to Arroyo, who picked up the ball and ran to the baseline to tag Rodriguez out, but Rodriguez slapped Arroyo's arm, knocking the ball loose. While the ball rolled down the baseline, Rodriguez went to second and Jeter scored. After another long conversation among the umpires, Rodriguez was called out for
interference
and Jeter was ordered back to first, thus wiping out the score. The call further incensed the Yankee fans, already irate over the home run call in the fourth. As Torre and Rodriguez continued to frenetically argue with the umpires, many fans began to throw balls and other debris onto the field. Boston manager
Terry Francona
pulled his players from the field to protect them. After a delay, order was restored, and Arroyo got out of the inning unscathed. In the top of the ninth, after a leadoff single by
Jason Varitek
, his third hit of the night, off
Paul Quantrill
(the game 4 loser), the Yankees attempted to turn a double play. However, on a very close play,
Orlando Cabrera
was called safe at first base. This was the third time in the game that the frustrated New York fan base had a close call go against their team, and they again showered the field with debris. As the Yankees made a pitching change to insert
Tanyon Sturtze
into the game to relieve Quantrill, home plate umpire
Joe West
conversed with New York City mayor
Michael Bloomberg
, MLB security director Kevin Hallinan, and various
NYPD
officials. Shortly after this, Sturtze was told to stop his warmup, and NYPD officers began streaming out of the dugouts, and took the field in full riot gear. The police remained on the field, near the first and third base walls, for the remainder of the top of the ninth. When the game resumed, Sturtze did get out of the inning, stranding Cabrera. The police vacated the field during the break between innings. Red Sox closer
Keith Foulke
came in for the bottom of the ninth and allowed a walk to Matsui, striking out Bernie Williams, getting Jorge Posada to pop out to third, and walking Ruben Sierra, bringing
Tony Clark
to the plate as the potential pennant-winning run, but Clark struck out swinging on a
full count
to end the game.
Five previous teams had managed to win one game after going down 3?0 in a post-season series. Of these five, two made it to a Game 6. But now the Red Sox, the 26th team in Major League Baseball playoff history to face a 3?0 series deficit, became the first to force a Game Seven.
After the game, Schilling proudly wore his shirt with the Red Sox's motto, "
Why Not Us?
" in the locker room and during the press conferences.
[36]
Game 7
[
edit
]
Wednesday, October 20, 2004, at
Yankee Stadium (I)
in
Bronx, New York
For inspiration for their ALCS comeback, the Red Sox gathered in Yankee Stadium's visitors' clubhouse prior to Game 7 to watch
Miracle
, the movie chronicling the
1980 U.S. men's gold-medal hockey team
. The Yankees meanwhile, had
Bucky Dent
, the hero of the Yankees' one-game playoff against Boston in 1978, throw out the ceremonial first pitch.
Game 7 began at 8:30 p.m. The starting pitchers were
Derek Lowe
for the Red Sox and
Kevin Brown
for the Yankees.
Johnny Damon
led off the game with a single to left and stolen base, but was thrown out at home trying to score on a
Manny Ramirez
base hit. The very next pitch, however, was lined into the right-field bleachers by
David Ortiz
to give Boston a 2?0 advantage. After the Yankees went down in order in the first inning, Brown retired
Trot Nixon
on a groundout to begin the top of the second, but
Kevin Millar
singled to center field before Brown walked
Bill Mueller
and
Orlando Cabrera
to load the bases. Torre then replaced Brown with
Javier Vazquez
to face Johnny Damon, who hammered his first pitch into the right-field seats for a grand slam to make the score 6?0 Boston. Lowe, meanwhile, on two days rest, pitched six innings, allowing only one run on one hit when
Miguel Cairo
was hit by a pitch in the third, stole second, and scored on
Derek Jeter
's single. Vazquez walked Cabrera to lead off the fourth before Damon again homered on his first pitch to make it 8?1 Boston and give him three hits and six RBIs in this game. After walking two batters, Vazquez was relieved by
Esteban Loaiza
, who allowed a single to
Jason Varitek
to load the bases before retiring
Trot Nixon
and
Kevin Millar
to end the inning. Loaiza then threw three shutout innings, allowing three hits.
Pedro Martinez
relieved Lowe in the seventh inning, receiving loud chants of "Who's Your Daddy?," which intensified as he gave up a
leadoff double to
Hideki Matsui
, who scored on
Bernie Williams
's double. After
Jorge Posada
grounded out, Williams scored on
Kenny Lofton
's single, but
John Olerud
struck out and Cairo flew out to end the inning. In the eighth,
Mark Bellhorn
homered for the second night in a row off of
Tom Gordon
to make it 9?3 Boston. Next inning, Nixon hit a leadoff single, advanced to second on a
Doug Mientkiewicz
single, then went to third on a Mueller fly out before scoring on a sacrifice fly by Cabrera.
Mariano Rivera
relieved Gordon and retired Damon to end the inning.
Mike Timlin
pitched a scoreless eighth and started the 9th for the Red Sox, but allowed a leadoff single to Matsui and walked Lofton with two outs.
Alan Embree
was brought in to finish the game for Boston. At 12:01 am, on October 21, Ruben Sierra hit a groundball to second baseman
Pokey Reese
, who threw to first baseman Doug Mientkiewicz to finish the unprecedented comeback. It was their first pennant since 1986. The Red Sox won 10?3 and became the third team in sports history and the first since the
1975
NHL's
New York Islanders
to win a seven-game series after losing the first three games. For the Yankees, this was their first time losing an ALCS in eight appearances (their last ALCS elimination was in
1980
). David Ortiz was named the series MVP.
A
riot
broke out near Fenway Park in Boston following the series win, in which
Victoria Snelgrove
, an
Emerson College
journalism student, was accidentally shot and killed by police with an
FN 303
pepper spray
crowd-controlling
projectile
round.
[37]
[38]
This was the last ALCS game at the Old Yankee Stadium.
Composite box
[
edit
]
2004 ALCS
(4?3):
Boston Red Sox
over
New York Yankees
The total runs scored (86) makes the 2004 ALCS the highest scoring 7-game series in MLB history.
Team
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
11
|
12
|
13
|
14
|
R
|
H
|
E
|
Boston Red Sox
|
4
|
8
|
2
|
6
|
3
|
0
|
7
|
6
|
2
|
0
|
0
|
2
|
0
|
1
|
41
|
75
|
1
|
New York Yankees
|
6
|
1
|
10
|
5
|
2
|
9
|
7
|
3
|
2
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
45
|
78
|
4
|
Total attendance:
329,600
Average attendance:
47,086
|
Records
[
edit
]
- The Red Sox became the first Major League team to win eight straight postseason games in the same postseason (four straight in the ALCS and four consecutive games in the World Series). The Oakland Athletics had won ten straight postseason games, but they were spread out over two postseasons (the 1989 ALCS and
World Series
, and the 1990 ALCS). The New York Yankees won 11 straight games also over two consecutive postseasons (the 1998 ALCS and
World Series
through the 1999 ALDS and into the 1999 ALCS). The
2005 Chicago White Sox
repeated this feat, as did the
2014 Kansas City Royals
and
2019 Washington Nationals
.
- The Red Sox became the third team in North American sports history to lose the first three games of a best-of-seven series and win the last four,
[39]
joining the 1942 Toronto Maple Leafs and 1975 New York Islanders of the
NHL
.
[39]
Boston's NHL franchise, the
Bruins
, would find themselves on the wrong side of the feat in
2010
, losing to the
Philadelphia Flyers
in the Eastern Conference semifinals.
[40]
- At 4 hours and 20 minutes Game 3 was, at the time, the longest nine-inning postseason game in MLB history. That record stood until Game 5 of the
2016 National League Division Series
between the Dodgers and Nationals, which took 4:32.
[34]
[41]
The current Red Sox record is Game 4 of their
2018 American League Championship Series
against the
Houston Astros
, which took 4:33;
[42]
the MLB record is now held by the
Cleveland Indians
and Yankees in Game 2 of the
2020 American League Wild Card Series
, which lasted 4:50.
[43]
- In Game 3, Yankee left fielder Hideki Matsui had five hits and five RBIs, tying an American League Championship Series record.
- Game 5, at 5 hours and 49 minutes,
[44]
was the longest Major League postseason game in history at the time. The record stood until Game 4 of the
2005 National League Division Series
between the
Astros
and the
Atlanta Braves
, an 18-inning game that lasted 5:50. The current MLB record is held by Game 3 of the
2018 World Series
between the Red Sox and the
Los Angeles Dodgers
, which also lasted 18 innings and took 7:20 to play.
- David Ortiz
became the first player to hit two walk-off HRs in the same postseason,
2004 American League Division Series
Game 3 and 2004 ALCS Game 4.
[45]
Aftermath
[
edit
]
After dominating much of baseball since 1996, this would be the closest that the Joe Torre-led Yankees would get to going back to the World Series. They would not get back until 2009 (by which point
Joe Girardi
had taken over the manager position) when they beat defending champion
Philadelphia Phillies
in six games.
The Yankees signed
Johnny Damon
away from the Red Sox after the 2005 season.
[46]
In an interview with
Jomboy Media
in 2021, Damon stated he wanted to stay in Boston, but he believed Red Sox management weren't interested in keeping him due to the emergence of top prospect
Jacoby Ellsbury
, who scouts compared to Damon.
[47]
Ironically, Ellsbury would sign with the Yankees as a free agent after a long and successful career in Boston, like Damon.
This series is often seen as a turning point of the
Yankees?Red Sox rivalry
, which up until this point, was almost entirely dominated by the Yankees.
[48]
[49]
From the time the Red Sox's owner
Harry Frazee
traded
Babe Ruth
to the Yankees for cash on January 5, 1920, through October 2004, the Yankees were the premier team in baseball, winning a record 26 World Series and 39 pennants in between then. On the other hand, the Red Sox, who were Major League Baseball's most successful franchise until the Ruth trade in 1920, only won a handful of pennants, losing every World Series they played in. However, since 2004, the Red Sox have won four World Series compared to just one Yankees World Series (the Yankees still have superior regular season winning percentage than the Red Sox since 2004). The 2010s was the first ever decade the Yankees franchise did not play in the World Series since the 1910s, and the first in which they did not win a World Series since the 1980s. In the same decade, the Red Sox won a World Series in
2013
and
2018
. On their way to a championship in 2018, the Red Sox defeated the Yankees, now led by Aaron Boone as manager, in four games in the
American League Division Series
, which was the first postseason match-up between the two rivals since the 2004 AL Championship Series.
In 2010, ESPN's
30 for 30
featured a documentary named "
Four Days in October
", which went into depth of the Red Sox's triumph over the Yankees in the 2004 AL Championship Series over the course of 4 days.
[50]
In 2020, the
Houston Astros
nearly came back from a
3?0 series deficit
, but lost in Game 7 of the
AL Championship Series
to the
Tampa Bay Rays
. It was the closest a team in
Major League Baseball
had come to pulling off this feat since the
2004 Red Sox
. In the
National Hockey League
, the
2010 Philadelphia Flyers
became the first NHL team to comeback from a 3?0 deficit since the
New York Islanders
did it
1975
(they coincidentally beat a team from Boston, the
Bruins
, in the
2010 Eastern Conference Semifinals
to accomplish the feat) en route to the
Stanley Cup Finals
. Four years later in 2014, the
Los Angeles Kings
came back from 3?0 in a series with the
San Jose Sharks
in the
Western Conference First Round
en route to
winning the Stanley Cup
. To date, no
NBA
team has ever come back from a 3?0 postseason deficit.
In 2021, the Red Sox and Yankees would once again face off in the postseason, with the Red Sox winning the
American League Wild Card Game
by a score of 6?2.
[51]
In the
2022 American League Championship Series
, prior to Game 4 against Astros, Boone had the team mental skills coach show clips from the 2004 series to the team as an attempt at motivating the Yankees, who were down 3-0 in the 2022 series; the Yankees promptly lost Game 4 and were thus eliminated.
[52]
References
[
edit
]
- ^
Shaughnessy, Dan (October 13, 2004). "An Opening Night Shortfall; Red Sox Rally but Lose Game 1 to Yankees, 10–7".
The Boston Globe
. p. A1.
- ^
a
b
c
d
e
f
Shaughnessy, Dan
(October 17, 2004). "Red Sox on brink of elimination as Yanks pound them, 19?8".
Boston Globe
. p. A1.
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, pp. 197?199
- ^
Cleveland, Jeffery (February 24, 2013).
"Curt Schilling's bloody sock sells for $92,613 at auction"
.
USA Today
. Retrieved
June 27,
2015
.
- ^
Shaughnessy, Dan (October 21, 2004).
"A World Series ticket; Sox complete comeback, oust Yankees for AL title"
.
The Boston Globe
. p. A1.
- ^
"2003 American League Championship Series (ALCS) Game 7"
. Baseball-reference
. Retrieved
July 16,
2010
.
- ^
"Schilling rarin' to go for Bosox"
.
USA Today
. November 28, 2003
. Retrieved
July 16,
2010
.
- ^
"Move had been expected by many"
. ESPN. October 27, 2003
. Retrieved
July 16,
2010
.
- ^
"Foulke signs three-year deal with Red Sox"
. ESPN. Associated Press. December 17, 2003
. Retrieved
July 15,
2008
.
- ^
a
b
"2004 Boston Red Sox Schedule, Box Scores and Splits"
. Baseball-reference
. Retrieved
July 17,
2010
.
- ^
a
b
c
d
e
Jenkins, Lee (October 12, 2004).
"With a New Spirit, The Red Sox Tackle Their Haunted Past"
.
New York Times
. p. A1.
- ^
"No more Nomar"
.
Sports Illustrated
. Associated Press. July 31, 2004
. Retrieved
July 15,
2009
.
- ^
a
b
"2004 American League Team Statistics and Standings"
. Baseball-Reference
. Retrieved
July 17,
2010
.
- ^
a
b
DiGiovanna, Mike (October 12, 2004). "They Love to Hate Each Other; Red Sox and Yankees carry bitter rivalry into championship series that starts tonight".
Los Angeles Times
. p. D1.
- ^
Blum, Ronald (October 10, 2004). "Red Sox and Yankees, the matchup they wanted". Associated Press.
- ^
Golen, Jimmy (October 11, 2004). "These Red Sox think they're better than '03 team". Associated Press.
- ^
2004 World Series
(DVD). Major League Baseball Productions. 2004.
- ^
Major League Baseball on Fox: Game 1 of 2004 American League Championship Series
(television). Fox Sports. October 12, 2004.
- ^
2004 ALCS Game 1 Red Sox at Yankees Full Game 60 fps
on
YouTube
- ^
a
b
c
Shaughnessy, Dan
(October 12, 2004). "The classic rivalry resumes Sox, Yankees begin battle tonight for trip to World Series".
Boston Globe
. p. A1.
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, p. 186
- ^
a
b
The rescheduling plan was originally for Game 5, had Game 4 not been delayed one day by rain.
- ^
a
b
Ryan, Bob
(October 12, 2004). "Fox's Sunday Lineup a Bonanza for Boston".
Boston Globe
. p. F2.
The Sox-Yankees Game 5 originally was set for a 4:30 pm first pitch. Concerns over where to send the Boston market if the football game ran long had to be a consideration in flopping the ALCS and NLCS starting times.
- ^
"ALCS Game 5 moved to prime time on Sunday, Oct. 17"
. Major League Baseball. October 11, 2004. Archived from
the original
on March 21, 2010
. Retrieved
July 25,
2011
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 1 ? Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 2 ? Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 3 ? New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 4 ? New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 5 ? New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 6 ? Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
"2004 ALCS Game 7 ? Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees"
. Retrosheet
. Retrieved
September 13,
2009
.
- ^
Hohler, Bob (October 16, 2004). "Gloom was in forecast; MLB postponed game after consulting various sources".
Boston Globe
. p. E2.
- ^
Shaughnessy, Dan (October 16, 2004). "There's been no reign after delays".
Boston Globe
. p. E1.
- ^
a
b
Shaughnessy 2005
, pp. 193?194
- ^
Ryan, Bob
(October 17, 2004). "Even by their standards, this is a new low".
Boston Globe
. p. E1.
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, p. 188
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, p. 218
- ^
"College student dies after police shoot projectile into postgame crowd"
.
The Marshall News Messenger
.
Marshall, Texas
.
AP
. October 21, 2004
. Retrieved
March 15,
2020
– via newspapers.com.
- ^
a
b
"A Look At The 5 Comebacks From 3-0 Down In Sports History"
. October 21, 2015
. Retrieved
September 10,
2016
.
- ^
"Bruins' collapse cuts to heart"
.
ESPN.com
. May 15, 2010
. Retrieved
September 10,
2016
.
- ^
"Dodgers - Nationals NLDS Game 5 Was the Longest 9-Inning Postseason Game Ever"
. October 14, 2016.
- ^
"Red Sox 8, Astros 6 (Final Score) on MLB Gameday"
.
MLB.com
.
- ^
"Yankees/Indians was longest 9-inning game in MLB history"
.
www.msn.com
. Retrieved
June 1,
2021
.
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, p. 202
- ^
Shaughnessy 2005
, p. 199
- ^
"Yankees add Damon to potent lineup"
.
ESPN.com
. December 21, 2005
. Retrieved
July 30,
2022
.
- ^
Media, Jomboy.
"Johnny Damon remembers going to Yankees because the Red Sox weren't truthful with him"
.
YouTube
. Retrieved
July 30,
2022
.
- ^
The Turning Point | The Best Rivalry in Baseball (Yankees vs. Red Sox)
, retrieved
August 20,
2022
- ^
"It's Been 11 Years Since the 2004 Red Sox Beat the Yankees"
.
Boston Magazine
. October 20, 2015
. Retrieved
August 20,
2022
.
- ^
"Four Days in October - ESPN Films: 30 for 30"
.
www.espn.com
. Retrieved
August 20,
2022
.
- ^
Dougherty, Jesse (October 5, 2021).
"Red Sox, better when it mattered most, top Yankees in AL wild-card showdown"
.
Washington Post
. Retrieved
October 10,
2021
.
- ^
"Michael Kay blasts Aaron Boone, Yankees for 'tone deaf' decision to use 2004 Red Sox as inspiration"
.
www.cbssports.com
. Retrieved
August 6,
2023
.
Sources
[
edit
]
Links to related articles
|
---|
|
---|
| Franchise
| |
---|
Ballparks
| |
---|
Culture
| Fenway environs
| |
---|
Groups
| |
---|
Individuals
| |
---|
Music
| |
---|
Entertainment
| |
---|
|
---|
Lore
| |
---|
Rivalries
| |
---|
Administration
| |
---|
World Series championships (9)
| |
---|
American League pennants (14)
| |
---|
Division championships (10)
| |
---|
Wild card berths (8)
| |
---|
Minor league affiliates
| |
---|
Broadcasting
| |
---|
Seasons (124)
|
---|
1900s
| |
---|
1910s
| |
---|
1920s
| |
---|
1930s
| |
---|
1940s
| |
---|
1950s
| |
---|
1960s
| |
---|
1970s
| |
---|
1980s
| |
---|
1990s
| |
---|
2000s
| |
---|
2010s
| |
---|
2020s
| |
---|
| |
|
---|
| Franchise
| |
---|
Ballparks
| |
---|
Culture
| |
---|
Lore
| |
---|
Rivalries
| |
---|
Monument Park
honorees
| |
---|
Key personnel
| |
---|
Championships (27)
| |
---|
American League
Pennants (40)
| |
---|
Division titles (20)
| |
---|
Wild Card titles (7)
| |
---|
Minors
|
- Triple-A
- Double-A
- High-A
- Single-A
- Rookie
|
---|
Seasons (124)
|
---|
1900s
| |
---|
1910s
| |
---|
1920s
| |
---|
1930s
| |
---|
1940s
| |
---|
1950s
| |
---|
1960s
| |
---|
1970s
| |
---|
1980s
| |
---|
1990s
| |
---|
2000s
| |
---|
2010s
| |
---|
2020s
| |
---|
|
|
---|
Related programs
| |
---|
Related articles
| National
coverage
| |
---|
Former
FSN
regional coverage
| |
---|
Fox/MyTV
O&O Stations
|
- New York City:
WNYW 5
(Yankees,
1999?2001
),
WWOR 9
(N.Y. Giants,
1951?1957
; Brooklyn Dodgers,
1950?1957
; Mets,
1962?1998
; Yankees,
2005?2014
)
- Los Angeles:
KTTV 11
(Dodgers,
1958?1992
),
KCOP 13
(Dodgers,
2002?2005
; Angels,
2006?2012
)
- Chicago:
WFLD 32
(White Sox,
1968?1972
,
1982?1989
)
- Philadelphia:
WTXF 29
(Phillies,
1983?1989
)
- Dallas?Fort Worth:
KDFW 4
&
KDFI 27
(Texas Rangers,
2001?2009
)
- San Francisco?Oakland:
KTVU 2
(Giants,
1961?2007
; Athletics,
1973?1974
),
KICU 36
(Athletics,
1999?2008
)
- Boston:
WFXT 25
(Red Sox,
2000?2002
)
- Washington, D.C.:
WTTG 5
(Senators,
1948?1958
),
WDCA 20
(Nationals,
2005?2008
)
- Houston:
KRIV 26
(Astros,
1979?1982
),
KTXH 20
(Astros,
1983?1997
,
2008?2012
)
- Detroit:
WJBK 2
(Tigers,
1953?1974
;
2007
)
- Minneapolis?Saint Paul:
KMSP 9
(Twins,
1979?1988
,
1998?2002
),
WFTC 29
(Twins,
1990?1992
,
2005?2010
)
|
---|
TV history by decade
| |
---|
|
---|
Commentators
| Play-by-play
announcers
| Former play-by-play
announcers
| |
---|
|
---|
Color
commentators
|
|
---|
Guest
commentators
| |
---|
Field reporters
|
|
---|
Studio hosts
|
|
---|
Studio
analysts
|
|
---|
|
---|
Lore
| Regular season
| |
---|
Postseason games
| |
---|
World Series games
| |
---|
|
---|
World Series
| |
---|
AL Championship Series
| |
---|
NL Championship Series
| |
---|
AL Division Series
| |
---|
NL Division Series
| |
---|
All-Star Game
| |
---|
World Baseball Classic
| |
---|
|
---|
Play-by-play
| |
---|
Analysts
| |
---|
Studio hosts
| |
---|
AL Championship Series
| |
---|
NL Championship Series
| |
---|
AL Division Series
| |
---|
NL Division Series
| |
---|
AL Wild Card Round
| |
---|
NL Wild Card Round
| |
---|
All-Star Game
| |
---|
World Series
| |
---|
World Baseball Classic
| |
---|
Related programs
| |
---|
Commentators
| |
---|
Lore
|
|
---|
Related articles
| |
---|
|