§?17.
The Synod of Jerusalem and the Confession of Dositheus, A.D.
1672.
Hardouin:
Acta Conciliorum
(Paris, 1715), Tom. XI. pp. 179?274.
Kimmel
:
Monumenta Fidei Ecclesiæ Orientalis
, P. I. pp. 325?488;
Prolegomena
, pp. lxxv.?xcii.
On the Synod of Jerusalem, comp. also
Ittig
:
Dissert. de Actis Synodi Hieros. a.
1672
sub Patr. Hiers. Dositheo adv. Calvinistas habitæ
, Lips. 1696.
Aymon
:
Monuments authentiques de la religion des Grecs
, a la Haye, 1708.
Basnage
:
Hist. de la religion des eglises reformees
, P. I. ch. xxxii.
J. Covel
:
Account of the present Greek Church
, Bk. I. ch. v.
Schroeckh
:
Kirchengeschichte seit der Reformation
, Bd. ix. (by
Tzschirner
), pp. 90?96.
Gass
:
Symb. der griech. Kirche
, pp. 79-84.
The Synod convened at Jerusalem in March, 1672, by Patriarch Dositheus, for the consecration of the restored Church of the Holy Nativity in Bethlehem,
129
129
issued a new
Defense
or
Apology
of Greek
Orthodoxy
. It is directed against Calvinism, which was still professed or secretly held by many admirers of Cyril Lucar. It is dated Jerusalem, March 16, 1672, and signed by Dositheus, Patriarch of Jerusalem and Palestine (otherwise little known), and by sixty-eight Eastern bishops and ecclesiastics, including some from Russia.
130
130
This Synod is the most important in the modern history of the Eastern Church, and may be compared to the Council of Trent. Both fixed the doctrinal status of the Churches they represent, and both condemned the evangelical doctrines of Protestantism. Both were equally hierarchical and intolerant, and present a strange contrast to the first Synod held in Jerusalem, when 'the apostles
and elders
,' in the presence of 'the brethren,' freely discussed and adjusted, in a spirit of love, without anathemas, the great controversy between the Gentile and the Jewish Christians. The Synod of Jerusalem has been charged by Aymon and others with subserviency to the interests of Rome; Dositheus being in correspondence with Nointel, the French embassador at Constantinople. The Synod was held at a time when the Romanists and Calvinists in France fiercely disputed about the Eucharist, and were anxious to secure the support of the Greek Church. But although the Synod was chiefly aimed against Protestantism, and has no direct polemical reference
62
to the Latin Church, it did not give up any of the distinctive Greek doctrines, or make any concessions to the claims of the Papacy.
The acts of the Synod of Jerusalem consist of six chapters, and a confession of Dositheus in eighteen decrees. Both are preceded by a pastoral letter giving an account of the occasion of this public confession in opposition to Calvinism and Lutheranism, which are condemned alike as being essentially the same heresy, notwithstanding some apparent differences.
131
131
The Answers of Patriarch Jeremiah given to Martin Crusius, Professor in Tubingen, and other Lutherans, in 1572, are approved by the Synod of Jerusalem, as they were by the Synod of Jassy, and thus clothed with a semi-symbolical authority. The Orthodox Confession of Peter Mogilas is likewise sanctioned again, but the Confession of Cyril Lucar is disowned as a forgery.
The
Six Chapters
are very prolix, and altogether polemical against the Confession which was circulated under the name of Cyril Lucar, and give large extracts from his homilies preached before the clergy and people of Constantinople to prove his orthodoxy. One anathema is not considered sufficient, and a threefold anathema is hurled against the heretical doctrines.
The
Confessio Dosithei
presents, in eighteen decrees or articles,
132
132
a positive statement of the orthodox faith. It follows the order of Cyril's Confession, which it is intended to refute. It is the most authoritative and complete doctrinal deliverance of the modern Greek Church on the controverted articles. It was formally transmitted by the Eastern Patriarchs to the Russian Church in 1721, and through it to certain Bishops of the Church of England, as an ultimatum to be received without further question or conference by all who would be in communion with the Orthodox Church. The eighteen decrees were also published in a Russian version (1838), but with a number of omissions and qualifications,
133
133
showing that, after all, the Russian branch of the Greek
63
Church reserves to itself a certain freedom of further theological development. We give them here in a condensed summary from the original Greek:
Article I.?
The doctrine of the Holy Trinity, with the single procession of the Spirit. (
Πνε?μα ?γιον ?κ το? πατρ?? ?κπορευ?μενον.
Against the Latins.)
Article II.
?The Holy Scriptures must be interpreted, not by private judgment, but in accordance with the tradition of the Catholic Church, which can not err, or deceive, or be deceived, and is of equal authority with the Scriptures. (Essentially Romish, but without an infallible, visible head of the Church.)
Article III.
?God has from eternity predestinated to glory those who would, in his foreknowledge, make good use of their free will in accepting the salvation, and has condemned those who would reject it. The Calvinistic doctrine of unconditional predestination is condemned as abominable, impious, and blasphemous.
Article IV.
?The doctrine of creation. The triune God made all things, visible and invisible, except sin, which is contrary to his will, and originated in the Devil and in man.
Article V.
?The doctrine of Providence. God foresees and permits (but does not foreordain) evil, and overrules it for good.
Article VI.
?The primitive state and fall of man. Christ and the Virgin Mary are exempt from sin.
Article VII.
?The doctrine of the incarnation of the Son of God, his death, resurrection, ascension, and return to judgment.
Article VIII.
?The work of Christ. He is the only Mediator and Advocate for our sins; but the saints, and especially the immaculate Mother of our Lord, as also the holy angels, bring our prayers and petitions before him, and give them greater effect.
Article IX.
?No one can be saved without faith, which is a certain persuasion, and works by love (i.e. the observance of the divine commandments). It justifies before Christ, and without it no one can please God.
Article X.
?The holy Catholic and Apostolic Church comprehends
64
all true believers in Christ, and is governed by Christ, the only head, through duly ordained bishops in unbroken succession. The doctrine of Calvinists, that bishops are not necessary, or that priests (presbyters) may be ordained by priests, and not by bishops only, is rejected.
Article XI.
?Members of the Catholic Church are all the faithful, who firmly hold the faith of Christ as delivered by him, the apostles, and the holy synods, although some of them may be subject to various sins.
Article XII.
?The Catholic Church is taught by the Holy Ghost, through prophets, apostles, holy fathers, and synods, and therefore can not err, or be deceived, or choose a lie for the truth. (Against Cyril; comp. Art. II.)
Article XIII.
?Man is justified, not by faith alone, but also by works.
Article XIV.
?Man has been debilitated by the fall, and lost the perfection and freedom from suffering, but not his intellectual and moral nature. He has still the free will (
τ? α?τεξο?σιον
) or the power to choose and do good or to flee and hate evil (
Matt. v. 46, 47
;
Rom. i. 19
;
ii. 14, 15
). But good works done without faith can not contribute to our salvation; only the works of the regenerate, done under grace and with grace, are perfect, and render the one who does them worthy of salvation (
σωτηρ?α? ?ξιον ποιε?ται τ?ν ?νεργο?ντα
).
Article XV.
?Teaches, with the Roman Church, the seven sacraments or mysteries (
μυστ?ρια
), viz., baptism (
τ? ?γιον β?πτισμα,
Matt. xxviii. 19
), confirmation (
βεβα?ωσι?
or
χρ?σμα,
Luke xxiv. 49
;
2 Cor. i. 21
; and Dionysius Areop.), ordination (
?εροσ?νη,
Matt. xviii. 18
), the unbloody sacrifice of the altar (
? ?να?μακτο? θυσ?α,
Matt. xxvi. 26
, etc.), matrimony (
γ?μο?,
Matt. xix. 6
;
Eph. v. 32
), penance and confession (
μετ?νοια κα? ?ξομολ?γησι?,
John xx. 23
;
Luke xiii. 3, 5
), and holy unction (
τ? ?γιον ?λαιον
or
ε?χ?λαιον,
Mark vi. 13
;
James v. 14
). Sacraments are not empty signs of divine promises (as circumcision), but they necessarily (
?ξ ?ν?γκη?
) confer grace (as
?ργανα δραστικ? χ?ριτο?
).
Article XVI.
?Teaches the necessity of baptism for salvation, baptismal regeneration (
John iii. 5
), infant baptism, and the salvation of baptized infants (
Matt. xix. 12
). The effect of baptism is the remission of hereditary and previous actual sin, and the gift of the Holy Spirit. It can not be repeated; sins committed after baptism must be forgiven by priestly absolution on repentance and confession.
65
Article XVII.
?The Eucharist is both a sacrament and a sacrifice, in which the very body and blood of Christ are truly and really (
?ληθ?? κα? πραγματικ??
) present under the figure and type (
?ν ε?δει κα? τ?π?
) of bread and wine, are offered to God by the hands of the priest as a real though unbloody sacrifice for all the faithful, whether living or dead (
?π?ρ π?ντων τ?ν ε?σεβ?ν ζ?ντων κα? τεθνε?των
), and are received by the hand and the mouth of unworthy as well as worthy communicants, though with opposite effects. The Lutheran doctrine is rejected, and the Romish doctrine of transubstantiation (
μεταβολ?, μετουσ?ωσι?
) is taught as strongly as words can make it;
134
134
but it is disclaimed to give an explanation of the
mode
in which this mysterious and miraculous change of the elements takes place.
135
135
Article XVIII.
?The souls of the departed are either at rest or in torment,
136
136
according to their conduct in life; but their condition will not be perfect till the resurrection of the body. The souls of those who die in a state of penitence (
μετανο?σαντε?
), without having brought forth fruits of repentance, or satisfactions (
?κανοπο?ησι?
), depart into Hades (
?π?ρχεσθαι ε?? ?δου
), and there they must suffer the punishment for their sins; but they may be delivered by the prayers of the priests and the alms of their kindred, especially by the unbloody sacrifice of the mass
66
(
μαγ?λα δυναμ?νη? μ?λιστα τ?? ?ναιμ?κτου θυσ?α?
), which individuals offer for their departed relatives, and which the Catholic and Apostolic Church daily offers for all alike. The liberation from this intervening state of purification will take place before the resurrection and the general judgment, but the time is unknown.
This is essentially the Romish doctrine of purgatory, although the term is avoided, and nothing is said of material or physical torments.
137
137
To these eighteen decrees are added four questions and answers, with polemic reference to the similar questions at the close of the enlarged edition of Cyril's Confession.
138
138
The first question discourages and even prohibits the general and indiscriminate reading of the Holy Scriptures, especially certain portions of the Old Testament. The second denies the perspicuity of the Scriptures. The third defines the extent of the canon including the Apocrypha.
139
139
The fourth teaches the worship of saints, especially the Mother of God (who is the object of
67
hyperdulia,
as distinct from the ordinary
dulia
of saints, and the
latria
or worship proper due to God), as also the worshipful veneration of the cross, the holy Gospels, the holy vessels, the holy places,
140
140
and of the images of Christ and of the saints.
141
141
In all these important points the Synod of Jerusalem again essentially agrees with the Church of Rome, and radically dissents from Protestantism.