From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This is a list of websites covering or discussing
the legal threat delivered to me by representatives of the National Portrait Gallery, London on July 10, 2009
. Please feel free to edit this list to mark or remove dead links, or to organize the stories further.
Summary of top stories
[
edit
]
- BBC: Gallery in Wikipedia legal threat
, 15 July 2009
- BBC: Wikipedia painting row escalates
, Rory Cellan-Jones, 17 July 2009
- Wikimedia blog: Protecting the public domain and sharing our cultural heritage
, Erik Moller, 16 July 2009
- Deeplinks: EFF Defends Wikipedian's Right to the Public Domain
, Electronic Frontier Foundation, 3 August 2009
- Slashdot: UK's National Portrait Gallery Threatens To Sue Wikipedia User
, 11 July 2009
- Slashdot: New developments in NPG/Wikipedia lawsuit threat
, Raul654, 17 July 2009
- New York Times: Wikipedia May Be a Font of Facts, but It’s a Desert for Photos
, Noam Cohen, 20 July 2009
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion: Whose Art Is It, Anyway?
, Eric Felten
- London Evening Standard: National Portrait Gallery launches legal battle against Wikipedia
, 14 July 2009
- The Independent: Drawing up battle lines ? art gallery takes on Wikipedia
, Andrew Johnson, 18 July 2009
- The Register: National Portrait Gallery bitchslaps Wikipedia
, Andrew Orlowski, 13 July 2009
- The Register: Wikipedia's Gallery guy hung up to dry?
, Charles Eicher, 17 July 2009
- Techradar: Wikipedia slapped with National Portrait Gallery copyright order
, Marc Chacksfield, 13 July 2009
- Techradar: National Portrait Gallery responds to Wikipedia copyright case
, Marc Chacksfield, 14 July 2009
- Creative Commons: UK National Portrait Gallery threatens Wikipedia user over public domain images
, Joe Merante, 14 July 2009
- Open Rights Group: National Portrait Gallery vs Wikipedia
, Jim Killock, 21 July 2009
- Boing Boing: UK National Portrait Gallery threatens Wikipedia over scans of its public domain art
, Cory Doctorow, 20 July 2009
- Boing Boing: UK National Portrait Gallery threatens Wikipedia over scans of its public domain art
, Cory Doctorow
- TechDirt: Is The National Portrait Gallery Lying About The Cost Of Its Digital Archives In Fight With Wikimedia?
- Frank Wales: For the public? Good.
- TECH.BLORGE.com: Picture still murky in Wikipedia art gallery row
, John Lister
- robmyers: NPG Round-Up
, blog post by Rob Myers
- Dominato Per Malum: National Portrait Gallery v Wikipedia
- Likelihood of Confusion: A quick scan of the law regarding copyright and the public domain images
, Ron Coleman
- Citizen Media Law Project: Fight at the Museum: London's National Portrait Gallery Takes Aim at U.S. Wikipedia User
, Courtney French
- Harry Metcalfe: Should there be copyright in NPG’s photos?
- South African Artists: The Wikipedia/National Portrait Gallery spat continues...
, Mark Hayhurst
- Current Affairs: wikipedia flexes undemocratic muscle
, pete
- Digitisation, Copyright, and Public Interest
, Melissa
- BBC: Wikipedia painting row escalates
, Rory Cellan-Jones
(3rd most-shared BBC story at 14:03 UTC on 19 July 2009)
- The Register: Wikipedia's Gallery guy hung up to dry?
, Charles Eicher
- Xconomy: Art Isn’t Free: The Tragedy of the Wikimedia Commons
, Wade Roush
- David Gerard: NPG-WMF talks are in progress. What would you like to see from them?
- Slashdot: New developments in NPG/Wikipedia lawsuit threat
, Raul654
- IT PRO: Wikipedia fights back in Portrait Gallery row
, Nicole Kobie
- ITProPortal: British National Portrait Gallery Faces Wikipedia In Battle Over Paintings
, Desire Athow
- redOrbit: Dispute Between Wikipedia, Art Gallery Heats Up
- BayNewser: Wikimedia at Center of Trans-Atlantic Copyright Row
, E.B. Boyd
- Making a Mark: National Portrait Gallery versus Wikipedia - Round Two!
, blog post by Katherine Tyrrell
- Wikipedia Weekly: Episode 77: National Portrait Gallery challenge
(podcast)
- 38minutes: Why we need to get into the spirit of collaboration around our public art collections
, blog post by Anne Bonnar
- Bayou Renaissance Man: The copyright conundrum
, Peter
- Barklund.org: Why UK copyright law does extend copyright to the digitization of public domain works
- p2pnet: Old Nick and the National Portrait Gallery
- Surreptitious Evil: More Wikistupidity
- About.com: Marion's Painting Blog: The Paintings Belong to Everyone, But the Photos Don't
, Marion Boddy-Evans
- PlagiarismToday: 3 Count: Empire Building
, Jonathan Bailey (item 2)
- Jockohomo: U.K. National Portrait Gallery Threatens U.S. Citizen With Legal Action Over Wikimedia Images
- MobileRead forums: Wikipedia Painting Row (Public Domain Scan Issue)
- Words and what not: Why the NPG is wrong
, blog post by GerardM
- uk.politics.misc: Should anyone be allowed to download all the National Gallery's images and put them on another website?
- robmyers: National Portrait Gallery Fail
, blog post by Rob Myers
- Wikipedia and major UK art institution row over famous paintings
, forum discussion
- Scanlyze: Scanlyze Letter to UK National Portrait Gallery Regarding Wikipedia Controversy
- Techradar:Wikipedia slapped with National Portrait Gallery copyright order
, Marc Chacksfield
- The Register: National Portrait Gallery bitchslaps Wikipedia
, Andrew Orlowski
- bigmouthmedia: Wikipedia in hot water with National Portrait Gallery
, L. Sutherland
- Techdirt: National Portrait Gallery Threatens Wikimedia Developer For Downloading Public Domain Images
, Mike Masnick
- Slashdot: UK's National Portrait Gallery Threatens To Sue Wikipedia User
- Sue and be damned.
,
Has anyone been in touch with the National Portrait Gallery?
. Blog posts by David Gerard.
- The Londonist: National Portrait Gallery To Sue Wikipedia User?
. Matt Brown. UK.
- The Examiner: Wikipedia Might Get Sued By the National Portrait Gallery
, by Tim Worstall.
- Softpedia: British National Portrait Gallery May Sue Wikipedia User
- Expressive Lives - what should museums do with it?
, blog post by Bridget McKenzie.
- peoplepoints: Wikimedia Commons - National Portrait Gallery - Bleak House 2.0
. Paul Reynolds. New Zealand.
- PlagiarismToday: 3 Count: Round 2
, by Jonathan Bailey.
- Retro Yakking: London’s National Portrait Gallery could sue Wikipedia user
. Posted by user hindleyite.
- Foundation-l mailing list archive: About that "sue and be damned" to the National Portrait Gallery ...
- The Wikipedia Review: The National Portrait Gallery Threatens Litigation, Big Oops for WMF?
Discussion thread.
- NetBehaviour: UK's National Portrait Gallery Threatens To Sue Wikipedia User.
Mailing list archive.
- Indymedia UK: UK's National Portrait Gallery Threatens To Sue Wikipedia User
. John Dee.
- Ask the NPG to End Its Threats
. Protest campaign.
- Open...: National Portrait Gallery: Nuts
. Blog post by Glyn Moody.
- At last ... the 1709 Copyright Blog: Photo copyright: you say 'original' and I say 'slavish'
, blog post by Hugo.
- 405: National Portrait Gallery Sues Wikipedia User For Publishing Ancient Public Domain Images
, blog post by claytoncubitt
- banniNation.com: UK's National Portrait Gallery Threatens To Sue Wikipedia User
, forum discussion.
- D'log: Face off
- Commons:Village_pump#Legal_threat_from_National_Portrait_Gallery
- en:Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard#Legal_threat_by_National_Portrait_Gallery.2C_London
- Wikipedia Signpost: UK public gallery threatens Wikimedian
- S.I. Lex: Le domaine public en partage ? (A propos de l’affaire Wikipedia c. National Portrait Gallery)
, 30 July 2009
- Framablog: National Portrait Gallery vs Wikipedia ou la prise en etau et en otage de la Culture?
, including a translation of Erik Moeller's statement, 24 July 2009
- Artclair: Passe d’armes entre Wikipedia et la National Portrait Gallery
, 23 July 2009
- Paperblog: Desobeissance civile, des Titans a l'Assemblee, danse en Algerie
(last item), 22 July 2009
- Les Eclats de S.I.Lex: Plus de precisions sur l'affaire de "vol numerique" a la National Portrait Gallery
, 21 July 2009
- Les forums de Numerama: La nationnal portrait gallerie contre wikipedia
, 20 July 2009
- Neteco.com: Wikipedia et la NPG s'arrachent le portrait
- Arret sur images: National Portrait Gallery contre Wikipedia (The Independent)
, Gilles Klein, 19 July 2009
- CultureLibre.ca: Les photos du musee
, 17 July 2009
- Knoler.eu: Wikipedia en guerre contre NPG
, Xavier Pradel
- fr:Wikipedia:Le_Bistro/11_juillet_2009#Menace_de_poursuite_tr.C3.A8s_concr.C3.A8te_sur_Commons
- Benoit XVI aime Potter, la SDGL retarde, les facs pas bankables
(4th item)
- carnetsdudevoir.com: Vol virtuel? Le debat est ouvert...
, 15 July 2009
- Britische Museen offnen sich fur Wikimedia
Heise Online, February 2010
- Der Freitag: Wir sind so frei
, Friedhelm Greis, 25 July 2009
- TP: "Geistige Eigentumsrechte" auf 500 Jahre alte Bilder
, Peter Muhlbauer, 23 July 2009
- Wikimedia Blog: FAQ zum Disput National Portrait Gallery / Derrick Coetzee / Wikimedia Commons
, Mathias Schindler, 21 July 2009
- Telemedicus: NPG vs. Wikipedia: Schutz digitaler Reproduktionen
, Jan Wesselmann, 21 July 2009
- taz.de: Museum droht Wikipedia mit Klage
, Ben Schwan, 21 July 2009
- Archivalia: Inkompetentes Arthistoricum-Blog zu Bildrechten
, 19 July 2009
- PC-WELT: National Portrait Gallery verklagt Wikipedia-Nutzer
, 17 July 2009
- blog.arthistoricum.net: National Portrait Gallery vs. Wikimedia
, Georg Hohmann, 18 July 2009
- heise online: National Portrait Gallery streitet mit Wikipedia
- taz.de: Piraterie mit alten Olschinken
- presstexte austria: National Portrait Gallery geht gegen Wikianer vor
- Archivalia: UK: National Portrait Gallery legt sich mit Wikimedia Commons an
. Blog post by KlausGraf.
- VereinDE-l Wochenbericht Content Liberation - "your money at work" (27. J: msg#00014
. Mathias.
- historia i media: Granice domeny publicznej: Derrick Coetzee i National Portrait Gallery of London
, Marcin Wilkowski, 11 August 2009
- bblog.pl: Lege Artis: Reprodukcje dawnych obrazow to nie utwory (public domain)
, Olgierd Rudak, 4 August 2009
- Mobile Internet: Prawne problemy Wikipedii
, 23 July 2009
- ?Interaktywnie.com: Galeria kontra Wikipedia
, Bogumiła Matuszewska, 21 July 2009
- Dziennik.pl: Londy?ska galeria idzie na wojn? z Wikipedi?
, 19 July 2009
- Forum Wielotematyczne Nedds.pl: Londy?ska galeria idzie na wojn? z Wikipedi? Poszło o "przeklejenie" zdj??
, 19 July 2009
- heise online Polska: Spor mi?dzy Narodow? Galeri? Portretu a Wikipedi?
, 17 July 2009 (copy:
Gazeta.pl
)
- Terra: Tecnologia: Acusan a Wikipedia de 3.300 casos de violacion de autor
, 5 August 2009
- latercera.com: La National Portrait Gallery se enfrenta a Wikipedia
, Andres Oppenheimer, 4 August 2009
- Barrapunto: La National Portrait Gallery demanda a Wikipedia
, 3 August 2009
- El Pais.com: La National Portrait contra Wikipedia
, 2 August 2009
- canal-ar: ¿De quien es la cultura? National Portrait Gallery vs. Fundacion Wikimedia
, 2 August 2009
- educ.ar: Derechos y debe(res)
, 29 July 2009
- Página/12: La interminable guerra del copyright
, 22 July 2009
- Milenio: Crece la pugna contra el portal de Wikipedia
, Spanish translation of BBC piece, 21 July 2009
- Manzana Mecanica: Las fotos de la Wikipedia
, 21 July 2009
- Un museo de Londres demando a Wikipedia
- Meneame: Un museo londinense amenaza a un usuario de wikipedia con demandarle, por subir imágenes de cuadros de dominio público
. Blog post and discussion.
- Derecho a LEER: Museos quemando cuadros
, 25 July 2009
- El País (Uruguay): National Portrait Gallery demando a Wikipedia
, 14 July 2009
